Max and Issy's Pizzeria

it’s so good

Good flavor, really soupy in the middle. Crispy crust. May have been less floppy with plain cheese.

Flavorful and yummy. Crunchy crust. Cheese is A+. Sauce also tasty.

Really good pizza. Was a bit floppy on the ends but crispier towards the crust which was fire. Think if you ate it at the store it’d be better. I brought it home and didn’t hold great. Could’ve been more crisp. Will get again. Very good pie.

Great flavor, thin and crispy undercarriage. Perfect amount of toppings. Coming from Atlanta, this pizza is a 10.

Really good and did not disappoint. Staff were friendly and a good vibe!

Super light, really flavorful, good crisp, great undercarriage.

Never had a pizza like this outside of New York. Stellar.

Fantastic pie. Crisp was gorgeous, flavors were unreal. Electric place, good vibe.

Pros: super thin, light, well proportioned sauce/cheese, solid maillard on the cheese. Cons: floppy, no undercarriage color, no depth of flavor in the crust or sauce.

Great crust and sauce. Very surprising!

Best New York Style in Chicago.

Lots of flop on the carry out. But great flavors, great crust. Would probably be better eaten in restaurant. It’s a great attempt at a NY style pizza in the midwest!