Michael Angelo's Restaurant & Brick Oven Pizza

Inconsistent pizza quality, but I prefer when it’s more oily

The crust is amazing! Thin, crunchy, light, tangy sauce , quality cheese and ingredients

A bit saucy but it’s still works. Cheese and crust is amazing. It severely lacks some undercarriage to the point of everything falling off the slice. A corner has more integrity

I travel all around North America and hands down best pizza! I’ve even had it left over and still has tons of crisp. Sauce has a little tang that I love.

Great sauce, not really anything to improve on.

Pros: Loved it. Good proportion of cheese, sauce, and thin crust. Cons: maybe a little better quality dough/crust. A little pricey, but worth it.

The sauce is very flavorful. It’s thinner than it looks; soft on the bottom.

Ordered an old fashioned thin square pie. Sauce had tons of flavor (nice garlic taste), I could really taste the parmesan cheese. Crust had good flavor, only downside was it was very soft (zero crisp).

💎HIDDEN GEM ALERT💎 This might be one of New Jersey’s best kept pizza secrets. The main reason this pizza isn’t in the spotlight is due to its location. Off Route 46 in Fairfield, NJ literally hidden in the back of a Comfort Inn...not to mention they call themselves Michael Angelos of NEWARK! Not only is this a top tier pizza in New Jersey, this is the best square pie I’ve ever had in the Garden State. Thin crust, brick oven pizza with outstanding quality ingredients. The star of the pie is the outrageously delicious sauce. Sweet, tangy, bursting with garlic flavor and plenty of it to go around. While somewhat thick, the cheese has a wonderful consistency that melts in your mouth with each bite. A dusting of Parmesan helps neutralize the sweetness of the sauce and sops up any excess oil. The rich, buttery crust has a garlic bread taste to it with tremendous crisp. The only aspect of this pie holding back from breaking into the 9s is the somewhat soggy & spongy middle squares that need a little extra crisping in the oven. Other than that, this is a feast of flavors exploding from one of the most underrated/unknown pizzas in NJ. A primetime pie like this needs a prime location! Well worth making a trip if you’re looking for one of the best square pizzas in the Tri-state area.

Well worth the trip must try and some of the best sauce I've had. The only things holding it back is too little sauce and supper floppy middle. Will eat again. 8.4!!! (8.6 for the edges)

Great Sicilian with a thin crust and nice sauce. Owner is very accommodating. Definitely give them a shot.

Great pie best bar pizza i’ve have prob

Really tasty and unique pie. Thin Crust Brick Oven Square. Sauce is the star here, tangy and excellent. Meatballs were a quality addition.

Zeke with another treat!! A sucker for square pizza. This and Lazzara’s in time square now 2 of my favorite square pizzas. Tangy sauce, perfect amount of cheese. Crust could’ve been a little more crustier but am I blown away. A little gem found here in Fairfield. Zeke loves!!

Def unique. I’m really digging the tang from the cheese. Left side w pot cheese. Right side plain. Asked for slightly well done

Best pizza in Jersey🍕

One of the best pizza’s In NJ. Definitely most under rated crispy tangy

KTB says 8.2 but the rest of us are going 8.4, very good pizza, fresh and tasty!

Really good. Really really good. Pizza was fantastic. Had it as an appetizer then had another full meal. Everything was really good. Only got a picture of the sign tho.

I feel like this is the most underrated pizza in jersey. 🔥🔥🔥

This is legit. The sauce is tangy, super thin crust, and the cheese is light. Definitely order the old fashioned thin square pie, not just the regular. A little spendy but worth it. The taste reminds me of when Jeffrey Epstein didn't kill himself.