Michael's Original Pizzeria & Tavern

Second review for Michael's pizza. Second time back after Portnoy scored this place. Pizza was okay. Seemed like it went down in quality. Soft crust, not cooked enough. Sauce was way, way too sweet. Sorry, but I had to lower the score

ICKY

Picked up a thin & crispy and it was too rubbery halfway done. Eats like a skim milk mozz w white cheddar and parm. Thick tomato paste sugar sauce. Very mid at best, if you’re drunk.

Chicago deep dish style

No flop, sauce was sweet and tangy, cheese had a nice sturdiness to it and the meat toppings were good quality. Crust was nice and crispy and thin, great undercarriage!!

this one was really really close to cracking the 8’s for me. You can tell whoever cooked this pie knew what they were doing.

Ordered Delivery. Arrived a little cold. Not the restaurants fault (I blame GrubHub driver). Sauce is a little on the sweet side for me. Regardless, I powered through half of a 14’ pie. I enjoyed it!

Very good, pizza. If the sauce had more flavor, it would be in the 8's. Absolutely coming back.

Super thin crust. Good char. Sauce on the sweet side….excellent flavor. Good quality pepperoni. Love this place. 👍👍👍

Very good deep dish. Cheese was melted perfectly and crust had a nice crunch.

Very thin, crisp, good quality cheese.

One of the best pizza’s in all of Chicago!!! The crust is amazing, and the sauce is real tangy

Heard good things about Michael’s - didn’t disappoint! Perfectly cooked pizza with crispy crust and flavorful sausage. Sauce had a little sweetness to it. An elite tavern style pizza

Flakey crust is what drives this pizza. Thats great to hear since the sauce was pretty tame and the cheese did gum up from the parmesan used on top. Great late night pizza though. Beer would be nice with this one.

Very good thin crust, not greasy, good sauce and good toppings at a reasonable price

Good crisp, a little too thin for my preference.