I stopped at Mille Grazie with a friend since we've had pizza from here before. I remembered it being good, but I wanted to put it to the test in a proper review. I have had their penne slice a couple of times and that was notably good, but couldn't recall what the plain was like. As far as the plain goes, it is a very thin crust average Long Island slice. Honestly, there is not much to say about it because it is just very typical in regard to the sauce, cheese, and crust. The only thing I can really say is it had a little grease, but it was also very hot and taken straight out of the oven, so more understandable. It's a fine slice and if you're around, I'd have no problem recommending it. However, the penne slice was as good as I remember it, and I would definitely recommend you try that one at least once. It is quite hefty and will leave your pizza urges satisfied for sure, until a week later when you really want another one. Great soft penne on the slice, good penne sauce, and soft crust. Not the best pizza I've ever had, but it's pretty good. I'd give that one a 7.6 for being tasty.
Order now on Slice
Order Mille Grazie Pizzeria
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
tegan72912/6/22, 10:14 p.m.
Nice under carriage crisp to it but a little heavy on the cheese so it brought it down a little bit for me. I should have asked for it well done. Overall pretty tasty. The chicken/bacon slice was great.
greg.murphy49/27/22, 11:29 p.m.
Very tasty, no flop. Slightly chewy undercarriage and nice sauce. Also tried a sweet Thai chili slice and their MVP, which is an awesome grandma’s with pesto & vodka sauce.
jose.regal6/27/22, 9:53 p.m.
Very good flavor. Sauce on point. Light cheese. Not too much flop. Enjoyable solid NY slice. Also upside down Sicilian is the bomb
joseph.lanzarotta5/28/22, 2:32 p.m.
Probably one of the best upside down Sicilian slices I’ve had top of my list for this pizza you gotta try this slice here
sgtpet2/5/19, 10:28 p.m.
Floppy, sweet sauce. Good crust. Cheese is good but overpowered by the sweet sauce.
david.morales11/30/18, 8:06 p.m.
Very light. Could have used a little more flavor but solid slice
steven.d11/19/18, 8:27 p.m.
My family’s go to pizza place and my son’s first stop when he comes home from school. Great owners, who make you feel like you’re family. But the most important thing is the pizza and it is a very good slice, sauce slightly sweet with a touch of oregano, cheese nice and gooey and nicely cooked crust, this pizza when freshly made is earns a few tenths of a point while reheated it may lose a couple of tenths of a point, 7.9 is averaging the two. They have never failed me in all the years I’ve been ordering from them