Mimi's Pizza (3rd Ave & 86th)

Solid fresh slice

Fresh ingredients, crispy crust, you can really taste the tomato.

Classic cheese and margarita slice. Great quick bite when on the UES. Sauce tastes amazing and the crunch of the crust!

Sauce was too tart

Great crisp and not too cheesy or saucey. Couldn’t ask for much more out of a slice on the go!

Undercarriage on point 🤌

Good under carriage, crispy crust, good flavor. Needed a bit more sauce. Chicken parm hero was good 2

Sicilian pepperoni 8.4 Cheese & pepperoni slices 7.9

One of the better slices in UES. Perfectly crisp. If I were to nitpick, I would say it could use a little less cheese and the sauce could have a little more tang & sweetness. I would say low 8’s is pretty accurate.

Great sauce to cheese ratio. Excellent undercarriage. This is a perfect NYC slice.

Great slice, nice undercarriage and good overall ingredients

This score is for the grandma. Really nice square slice. It was thin but had a little bit more fluff in the crust. Tasted great. Really nice flavor. The regular was solid. A bit greasy and crust wasn’t doughy at all. I’d go a respectable 7.3 for that one. Come for the grandma though.

The perfect crispness. Wish it had a little more sauce

Good undercarriage and nice crunch. No flop and no grease.