Mister Pizza Elmwood

Not bad, go for the well done option if anything

Took a couple slices to go and ate them back home. Warmed them up in the toaster so I’m not sure how much crunch there usually is to this pizza. The cheese and pepperoni were good and I liked the sauce. My score seems to be higher than the latest scores and it might be because I reheat it better than what they give it to you as but it is what it is. Not gonna blow you away pizza but they’re open late so grab a slice after you’ve had a few beers.

Take Two for this review, this pizza had the best pepperoni so far in my buffalo pizza career. Odd shapes and extra thick I assume it’s hand cut in house. The cheese was good, sauce had a little more green taste then most. The flop was 9/10 if this was a little tighter it would bump it a couple points. Greasy just the way I like it and priced under $3 a slice. Definitely could see this pizza having a large spread on scores depending whom made it and what time of the day you eat it.

Not very good at all…I was really disappointed. The sauce is blah and it’s just soft doughy pizza. Not a fan!

The peps were crispy and substantial, there were grease stains under the slice, the crust didn't flip but was still fluffy- the 11pm slice hit just right, just like how Cinderella's slipper fit, this slice did everything I needed it to. Praise be mr🍕

Great slice

Not bad pizza. It’s a thicker style pizza, which I’m not a fan of. Cheese didn’t really have any flavor.

Back in the truck, if u know anything about buffalo the weather SUCKS rainy day=pizza day. BOOM HERE IT IS. 7.3 solid slice, no flop, crisp but like I said it’s something about the cheese and sauce combo and excess grease that couldn’t push this slice into 7.5 range but still a good pizza pizza. Samantha says 7.4

This pizza was very well done on the bottom. There was a lack of moisture on this pizza, definitely needs more sauce. Crust was crunchy and soft on the inside though so thats a plus and the cheese had a nice flavor. Overall a dry pizza but does the job

Lotta cheese lotta sauce

AB 8.3. The standard

good flavor, sauce doesn't overpower the cheese. however, it's a little too greasy, but not so much that it's gross. crust though was chewy, no crunch or crisp.

If it wasnt for the sqares, would have scored it over 7

Late night pizza review... It’s open late for people that have been drinking, but drunk pizza can’t be rated fairly. I’m sober but being drunk would probably help this review... It’s a little doughy but yet the bottom looked slightly over cooked. It is really greasy which made it a little softer. The crust had nice crisp and the cheese is decent. The sauce had a little tang to it and it’s average at best. The pepperoni is undercooked which indicates the oven cooks hotter on the bottom than top. This is good pizza drunk but it’s too greasy for my taste.

Ordered Well done

Cheese didn't taste fresh and nothing crazy on the sauce, crust at least had a crisp, not an appealing pizza

Just look at it.... tastes even worse if you can imagine. Absolutely horrible. Dry with 0 flavor.

Very good pizza, a little doughy, I like a little more crisp/char on my pizza but still very good

Coley’s first official review, so good.

Good

A bit of greaser slice, good pepperoni, cheese was good and sauce had some flavor. Would rate a bit higher if the crust didn’t have a burnt taste and smell.

Highest rating so far. 1st time Having it definitely won’t be the last