Where do I begin with this! I came here directly after leaving Sally's and being a little disappointed with their pie. I had slightly lower expectations with modern than I did for the big two on Wooster Street, but holy hell was this good! There was an hour and a half wait, but you can order takeout out of the side parking lot and get it in a much more timely manner, which is what I did. It took a little under a half hour before the cook brought my pizza right out of the back door of the kitchen. There was a nice fire pit in the rear of the parking lot which is where we ate LOL! The flavor on this pizza was unlike anything I'd ever had! Absolutely amazing sauce to go along with a nice airy crust with excellent crunch at the bottom! This was the best pizza I've ever had in my life, and I'm crossing my fingers that I can find a place that can top it!
lennoll15/17/22, 11:33 a.m.
The Best of today’s Big Three tour, edging out the more beautiful Sally’s and more legendary Pepe’s. This pie had perfect crust char and thickness, and delicious taste blend on sauce and cheese.
daniel.beem5/14/22, 5:19 p.m.
Probably would have scored it higher but I got a bubble on my first bite. Not a bubble man. But that is some good Za. Can’t wait to compare to other new haven favorites thanks Jon and Danielle!
2 views•0 likes
yankees315/10/22, 4:26 a.m.
Yet another New Haven greasy floppy mess. Nothing about this pizza was good. New haven still has Lois Lunch for burgers but that’s about it. Pizza in New Haven sucks moose balls
phillypizzaguy1235/8/22, 4:22 p.m.
Great crust, great cheese, great pepperoni, great char. Awesome Pie
rlee02714/26/22, 8:21 p.m.
plain -8.3 clam- 8.1. solid pizza but i don’t think it’s high 8s or 9s.
3 views•0 likes
doug.ward14/20/22, 7:50 p.m.
Really surprised that this didn’t score higher. Sauce was good but nowhere near the 8s. Crust was just a little over cooked. Overall disappointing pie
bsav78833/26/22, 7:01 p.m.
Great tasting sauce. We added some American cheese to a few slices different. Clam pie was awesome too.
michael.nunez33/25/22, 11:07 p.m.
Very good lil bit of a flop....but definitely a go to spot.... Thanks Dave
alex.overkamp3/25/22, 1:03 p.m.
Thursday lunch . We did bacon in whole pie and cherry peppers on half. Great char on crust (not too much). You can tell they use a quality bacon .