The people who give this a sub 4 are babies or expect it to hold up to other east coast staples. It’s fine. It sort of tastes like nothing. It has a fluffy crust, but definitely not as heavy as it looks. The cheese did congeal sort of quickly, and it was a bit light on the sauce. If you’re in Mystic, it’s a cool place to stop into, and you can try the pizza and see that it basically tastes like higher quality Domino’s with slightly less flavor.
lando_vision9/18/22, 2:41 a.m.
You get a papa johns kind of vibe from this pizza. I don’t think your there for the pizza, I think your there for the vibe over anything else. I won’t say this is bad pizza I’ll say it’a a place you bring your high school sweet heart to just to remind her that you still love her after all those years. Then you take a walk up the block with her and the watch the bridge go up together… Mystic pizza is a Vibe ladies and gentleman and you can’t knock that.
the happy.triathlete9/5/22, 1:56 a.m.
I’ve had better frozen pizza. Worst pizza I have had at a restaurant.
robpizzaguy8/3/22, 12:24 p.m.
The pizza is not that good, more like supermarket frozen pizza. It seems that people come here because of the movie, not the pizza. The staff is friendly.
frangelone8/1/22, 4:09 p.m.
Roller rink pizza, don’t expect something amazing but friendly staff and cool location
ryan.howard17/23/22, 9:46 p.m.
This pizza was very disappointing. Stopped here on our way back from Maine and wish we hadn’t. Very different rating than other east coast pies.
rob.shapiro16/26/22, 11:11 p.m.
Love the nostalgia but mainly because it tasted like Chuck E Cheese pizza.
2 views•1 like
mitch.gurevich6/17/22, 11:59 p.m.
A pretty cool place and very well known. It’s basically a decent Greek style pie not deserving of all the bad scores on the app. The cheese has a slightly unusual taste to it. I would bet it’s a blend
blake.archer16/6/22, 2:25 a.m.
Decent pizza but doesn’t live up to the chick flick hype ☹️
9 views•1 like
relax..eat.ur..meatballs6/5/22, 11:25 p.m.
We went there today with such anticipation I was warned that it wasn’t very good .. my slice honestly was under cooked doughy mess. Thick Neapolitan style crust .. i’m not sure about the other food they had a big restaurant but the pizza didn’t impress me
fg_football255/20/22, 7:26 p.m.
Mega flop and enough grease to cure a hangover for an entire month! Sauce was basic. Not bad football pizza! #Overhype
eric.nadeau5/17/22, 12:01 a.m.
This pizza flops harder than Kyrie Irving. It’s good tho. Nice sauce.
mr.saturdaynight5/6/22, 3:45 a.m.
Well this place was well worth the wait, I can tell you that much! The pizza was smaller than a normal pie but larger than a bar pie. It was thicker and had no flop and no runaway cheese for the amount of cheese on top. The sauce was sweet and the crust and undercarriage were crispy. I ate it right out of the oven and burned my friggen mouth up, but it was totally worth it!
john.glynn2/19/22, 5:51 p.m.
Light and fluffy. Looks heavier than it is. Not a ton of flavor in sauce or cheese, but not horrible. Slightly above average pizza with the famous name recognition
robbierackem2/12/22, 10:43 p.m.
Better quality Costco type pizza, I enjoyed it but I by no means blew my socks off. Very chewy and cheesy which made this a fun eat