Mystic Pizza

I watched the movie tonight and realized I never submitted a review for this place despite visiting three months ago. I can understand why locals view it as a tourist trap. It’s standard Greek-style pizza, but you’re there for the nostalgia and decor.

Not gonna monkey with tradition

I wouldn’t recommend the pizza but the ambiance and experience was top tier (and the underwhelming pie doesn’t change my love for the movie). Fried pickles - 7.8

Absolutely love this pizza. Very cheesy and very tasty. Could have used a little more sauce but overall amazing. The cast iron pan adds to the taste. Loved it

Didn't pass the flop test, but I felt like I was eating a very gourmet version of Pizza Hut

Sauce sucks, cheese eh, crunchy crust but no flavor. Took 1 bite turned into a mess. Only busy because of movie

Come here for the movie, not the pizza

Is OK pizza, limp and soft 80%, 20% crunch. OK carnival type pizza.

Not terrible, but I always hope it's better

Tastes like Pizza Hut pizza, that I can get anytime…. Not worth the hype!

Absolutely delicious!! They do not skimp on toppings, very cheesy, did not disappoint!

I’m not a big Greek Pizza fan but I’ve been to much better Greek style pizza places. This place is still living off of a movie from decades ago. It’s below average Greek pizza and not worth the trip unless you are just a huge Julia Roberts fan. There was actually a pizza review guy who made a video and said that this place was a 9.5 and blew Sally’s from New Haven out of the water. Just goes to show that some people have absolutely no clue whatsoever and should not be doing pizza reviews As far as Dave Portnoy I don’t agree with him often but on this one he’s 100%.

Very cheesy Very doughy I could see this being very good drunk pizza Understand this is historical pizza but have definitely had better pizza in NY and parts of CT

Tasted like a glorified Chuck E. Cheese pizza. I think it was more of a novelty slice.

Very bland. The pizza is kinda just there. Chucky cheese type of vibe of pizza.