Nancy's Towne House

Great atmosphere and solid pizza. Somewhat bland flavor profile so not 8s but very good

Great place, great pizza

EXCELLENT pizza!!!! Super light and crispy. Too easy to eat the whole thing. The flavors and everything were great. Would definitely drive extra to get this pizza. Just check the hours in the listing to make sure they’re open when you’re hungry. Can’t wait to get it again!

Yup….. super light, tangy, and crispy. got some nice char bites as well could easily eat entire pie

Very, very thin pie. Overall, it’s pretty good. 8.6 for me

Great light and crispy bar pie. Very little to no grease. Just delish! Cool looking place and great service. Me and the family come here any chance we get. My favorite pizza!

Dave was correct and spot on. Awesome cracker crust pizza. Ordered it with a little extra sauce. Taste was excellent. Great super thin crust pizza

My kind of slice!!! Cheesy with excellent flavor but no grease or gloop. Such a distinct crust that was razor thin (almost translucent) but so much crisp. Never had anything like it and will definitely be back.

Great bar pie.

Crazy on a Saturday. Would come back on a quieter weekday next time. Pizza was excellent. Super thin, crunchy crust topped with perfect sauce and cheese. Vibe of the place is the best. I’d go well into the 9’s if the crust had just a little give.

Tremendous crust, thin bar pie. Pete and Elda’s vibe, but better. Good sauce, cheese…not greasy. Wings were good also. Get there early…

Super crispy high quality za. My only criticism is that it was a little too oily for my liking

You can hear the crunch from space, Frankie!!

Greasy and crust makes your fingers black. Pretty good though

What do we got here? A disappointing pie from Dirty Jersey. Ice cold pizza, sauce tasted like Heinz, barely any cheese. I’ll give it this, if you are into the undercarriage then this is the pie for you. The undercarriage was outstanding. Only problem with that is you don’t eat pizza upside down. Maybe put some good stuff on top of your pie and then you’ll have a winning pizza. I know this place has a rep and maybe if you are in the place getting drunk like a irishman fucking a cat, then maybe it’s great pizza. But this isn’t worthy for a detour. It’s a small pizza and it will hardly fill ya up. If you coming into Staten Island stop by the pizzeria and keep on driving on route 9.

Nancy’s is old school joint that is week worth the ride to Rahway. Has its own parking lot in back and a couple of doors down is a decent brewery named Wet Ticket. The pizza is really good, crispy thin almost perfect bar pie. You won’t be disappointed.

I love bar pie!

Undercarriage: 1.3/2.5 (zero flop which is good but far too dry and cardboardy, recommend brushing some EVOO) Sauce: 0.5 (wasn’t enough sauce to notice, recommend adding some more) Cheese: 2.1 (cheese is the best part of this pie, stands out, good taste) End Crust: 0.3 (far too dry, tastes like a pita chip, recommend brushing some EVOO and adding some flavor, maybe some pecorino or garlic) Total Score: 4.2

Thin n crispy can never go wrong 🫶🏻

It has the looks and I love the crunch. The crust was a bit bland and had a “stale” after taste though. Toppings were great.

very good. not an 8.8, but again not the style i prefer

Exactly perfect. Has been that way since the 60’s when I started going. Crispy thin.