This place used to be AMAZING. Top 5 in all of NYC but now it’s hit or miss. Tonight it was good not great. The dough was floppy and chewy BUT the dough and crust have a great salty flavor. The sauce is sweet. Normally the salty dough and the sweet sauce made this pizza AMAZING. Problem is the pizza had zero crunch. It looked slightly undercooked. On a good day New Park can easily be an 8.5 but today it was a 7.5
siobhan.egan10/8/22, 4:50 p.m.
A little greasy but nice crisp. Guy was nice and warmed it up for us.
motelman10/7/22, 4:35 p.m.
Great sauce but they could give 2 shits about the product. Undercooked and sometimes served cold. In and out for $3.25 a slice. Shame since it could be in the high 8s if they cared.
jason.forman8/21/22, 3:24 p.m.
One of the best slices I have had in New York. The flavor of sauce and ratio to cheese is perfect. The dough has the right amount of crisp. Fell apart a little bit but everything else was there
cornelius19118/17/22, 11:44 p.m.
Honestly, they have been up and down for a couple of years, but on average this a really great spot.
santiago.zubillaga7/28/22, 11:12 p.m.
Second time at New Park. It was definitely better than the first time. The sauce and mozzarella were great—tasted somewhat similar to a Neapolitan pie but had that New York-style feel. A great place to stop by if you have to go to JFK.
brandon.jimenez27/13/22, 4:39 p.m.
Spot on with Dave’s review. Really good slice. Crust is excellent and doughy
jay.marine7/13/22, 12:14 a.m.
So, I was very excited to try this place ~ highly recommended by some people I work with, and for a bonus it’s kind of close to my old neighborhood when I was a wee lad. While waiting to order, my Lady & I were standing behind possibly the most obnoxious person I’ve ever encountered. 😂 Bunch of people on a line in an enclosed kind of tight area and this guy won’t shut the hell up on his Bluetooth. Talking at a volume 100, everyone on line hated him. We applauded when he left lol. As for the pizza. It took me by surprise honestly! First bite, I didn’t get it… was thinking “nothing great”, but with each bite I was liking it more and more. The crust is AMAZING. It was absolutely my favorite part. Cheese and sauce was good enough, but the crust was so light and fresh. Honestly, very VERY good. Look at the pic, you can see for yourself. I see why this place is so popular. I see Dave gave it the exact same score. Great minds… ay oh..
john.wis7/10/22, 3:26 a.m.
Great pizza! Good Cheese & Sauce! Very thin, BUT the flop.... too much... the outside has a great crust esp. if you get it well done, BUT too much flop. I would love to have this pizza but more crispy... That's a review ! Ciao
derek.rollins6/7/22, 3:22 p.m.
First time eating New York pizza had to go to a location el ores has been to.. amazing pizza gonna keep it at 8.1 crunch was great and listening to New Yorkers talk even more entertaining
emmanuel.moreno11/11/22, 8:32 p.m.
The crust was doughy but not too crunchy or floury. The cheese sauce ratio was perfect without too much oil. Of course the extra Parmesan black pepper and red pepper flakes on top complete it!