A must stop on the way home from Rockaway. Delicious
ryanloewy7/27/20, 4:26 p.m.
Damn it Frank, wish there was way more crisp to this floppy little fucker. Marinara is great, undercarriage has good texture, cheese was on par, little too much grease for my liking. Really could’ve seen these in the 8’s if it had some crisp to it. That’s a review Franklyn!!!
andrew.hunt16/30/20, 2:47 a.m.
Nice looking pie. Perfect crust but not much flavor. Good example of a classic NY pizza.
lnorinsky6/12/20, 5:29 p.m.
Good all-around Pizza. Nice char on the pizza, good crust and good sauce would be rated higher if it wasn’t so floopy
amordepizza4/8/20, 3:08 p.m.
What makes this pizza unique is that it is heavy on the cheese but still a light slice because the undercarriage is well done and light. Best part of this pizza is the well done and sometimes charred crust. If you get a crust like that is a bonus. You taste the oven and the love. Very solid slice.
matthew.croley4/4/20, 12:19 a.m.
Strange slice. SUPREMELY floppy, by far the floppiest slice I’ve had in NYC. Tomato flavor is completely absent, would have thought it was a white pizza if I’d been blindfolded. And the cheese was very, very, unpleasantly salty. Not my jam at all.
waviec3/13/20, 6:57 p.m.
Alright Frankie. If you get this pizza regular it’s only a 7.8. If you get it well done, it’s an 8.5. That’s a review
jason.cataldi2/15/20, 8:28 p.m.
Fresh, light, delicious. True NY staple that kept true over the years.
amory.blaine2/15/20, 2:22 p.m.
Enjoyed half white and half everything and also some gold medal slices.
hoe4pizza2/6/20, 4:31 a.m.
Could easily have 4 slices of this pizza. Always my first stop after a flight home. AMAZING pizza.
sgt.pizza1/29/20, 8:11 p.m.
Soft crust very greasy. Sauce and cheese are very delicious. Does not contain the wow factor
mike.peragine1/28/20, 9:11 p.m.
Def flop even with ordering well done. Ingredients are good, nice char, overall not the best slice but possibly the best around this area.
jtm27271/22/20, 3:34 a.m.
Ordered well done. Wildly inconsistent. Had five separate slices across two days (thank you, lunch-adjacent JFK flights). Two slices were great, probably in the 8.2-8.7 range. Two were average NYC slices. One was way too thin, to the point where it completely fell apart on me due to a hole in the crust. Quality of the slices, as well as saltiness of the crust, was so variable that I cannot accurately give a representative grade; this score reflects a general average.