New York Avenue Pizza

Closed . Used to have a real sweet sauce. Sunflower seeds on crust and solid pie. Damn you Covid for hurting small businesses

The sweet sauce slice is by far the best slice here and on the island! My intention tonight was to have 1-2 slices and ended up having 4. Crispy and well done undercarriage and perfect cheese to sauce ratio, can’t go wrong

Very good. Sweet sauce is tremendous.

We’ll known local spot. The “sweet sauce slice” is not like anything you will have tasted before. You can legit taste the sugar. Regular slice is up to par too. Fresh ingredients and great sesame seed crust

One of the best pizzas around. Great balance of sauce and cheese, no flop, not overly oiled and the sesame seed crust is delicious. Great flavor and consistency.

Giuseppe’s Pizza & Pasta Rating - 7.6/10 Sweet pie is very unique. 👌

Very sweet sauce. Great crust. Very unique. Sesame seeds! Decent crunch. Zero flop.

I was surprised by this excellent slice of pizza! Sweet Sauce was tasty. Sesame seed crust really good. This slice tasted different than the run of the mill.

This is not real pizza, it's Guiseppes. That is not an insult or derivative but a testament to why a pizza place like this should exist. It's a niche sweet slice that is amazing when done right and they also pack a few great gourmet slices. Excellent substitute for real pizza.

Should have taken a better photo bc this slice absolutely smacked. The crust has sesame seeds on it and the sauce was very tasty

Not to good, very plain. Got the traditional not sweet. Have had the sweet before, need to be in the mood for it.

Usually this is my favorite slice. Today was not the case. Super small, not much cheese, meltiness factor is low, disappointed. Would give an 8+ on any other day

I actually thought the sweet slice was pretty good but why wife almost kicked me out of the house when I brought a whole pie if it home....the sweetness made for an awful Saturday night of bitterness that's reflected in my score

Amazing grandma slice well done

Wow. Great slice. Good taste and perfect flavor. Just solid!

Good fuckin slice. I like this pizza a lot. If you’re coming here you gotta go with their signature sweet sauce pie. My tongue tingled a little when I took my first bite. Made my tastebuds dance like an episode of Glee. Thin sesame crust packs a nice crunch. Little sloppy on the presentation. Cheese sliding, a little too much grease. Still a good fuckin slice. 8.2 that’s a review.

Got the sweet slice and the flavor in the sauce delivered. Slice was relatively small. Crust was crisp and a bit greasy. Not too much of a fan of sesame seeds on pizza crusts though.

Best pizza I have ever had! Sweet sauce and crispy but soft dough with sesame seed crust is unreal