New York New York Pizza

Favorite slice in Ybor by far. They are consistent which is big to me. May be greasy at times but the undercarriage, cheese/sauce ratio and the staff are the jam. Partly because they remind me I look like Val Kilmer (back in the day/not now) when I grab a slice. But mainly because of the consistently good ‘New York style’ pizza. Tell Dave to come down here after watching the Bucs wax New England. Dave is cool though. So are the Bucs. But also New York New York

This pizza is a 9/10 when sauced but had it sober and it was alright

10 bites

Best pizza in Ybor friendly staff

Not even that bad for drunk pizza…But once again over priced..

Good ratio of sauce, cheese, and bread

What is that?

Good crust , sauce need a little work. Good pizza

Great thin crust. Sauce needs some work. No much flavor.

I've been to their Howard Ave location on the big Tampa party strip and thought it was fantastic. 1. I put my reputation on the line by bringing my 2 friends here for dinner. 2. The place did not let us down. This place would easily do well if in NYC. 3. Perfect dough that is thick but not doughy. Sauce and cheese absolutely perfect!!

Cooked perfect. Great crispy crust with an amazing sauce. My go to place in Ybor.

Fucking disgusting, obviously meant to feed the drunk and the incoherent not surprising especially cause it’s in in Ybor. Literally greasier than my grandmas fucking moist pussy. Would not recommend.

Alittle Greasy but still best pizza on 7th Ave

Solid slice. Lacks on the cheese, not much flop, crust was very crispy, almost too crispy for how thin it is. But overall, decent slice.

Not bad for Florida. I live in New England and wanted to go into the 6’s but back home this is a 5.1 at best. Solid slice though

Excellent pizza. Get the grandma.

very drunk n hungry thoe

A little greasy, but the crisp is legendary, a great under carriage, and a good cheese to sauce ratio. Got a couple of cheese slices, and they came out piping hot.

Good sauce

For Florida, not bad at all!

Solid NY style pizza, great crusy, a bit greasy but good sauce.

Good crisp needed a little bit more of cheese but good pizza overall