New York Pizza Depot

A place where you should only get the speciality slices. Regular slice is probably in the 5s. Substandard slice. Bumping the score up a point because I happen to enjoy their buffalo chicken, but nothing special. Probably does the job if you’re drunk, but that’s about it.

Pretty decent, fun environment

Decent slice a solid 6.2

Solid but not amazing

This is the best pizza in Ann Arbor. The crust is perfect, crispy on the bottom and soft on the inside. The sauce has the perfect balance of sweetness and acid. There’s just the right amount of cheese. Great overall flavor.

Two separate ratings. 1) I like the pizza. Good crust. No flop, although I don’t care either way. Been here many times when visiting Ann Arbor. What bothers me is 2) Dirty. That’s what I DO see. The girl behind the counter never greeted me or even looked up from sweeping the floor as I stood at the counter. She then proceeded to take mine and others orders and serving the food never washing her hands. There was more but that’s enough. Owners need to instill good hygiene… or at least fake it!

Nice crispy crust.

The One Bite Bro made the call. 7.5

New York Pizza Ann Arbor !

Good crunch, sauce and cheese are nothing special Average Ann Arbor slice

Skeeps is the only reason this place is open

The crust is the best part of the pizza. Great flavor/crunch/flop. There isn’t much to the sauce, pretty bland. Cheese didn’t have a great consistency.

Delightfully meh

The Drunk Slice of all Drunk Slices

As a NJ transplant this is the only place I’ve found in Michigan so far who can make the real NY style pie. That being said, compared to true NJ/NY pizza this is a 5.5. Compared to pizza in Michigan it’s an 8.1. They get the dough/crust right which is huge...but for cheese/sauce/flavor it’s just above average. Again bonus points on my score given this is in MI.

Nothing special

Regular cheese was shit. Sauce was like ketchup. Crust besides the flop was decent. The crust was good and made up for the the lack of decency that this pizza made. Apparently their Mac and cheese pizza is crazy good but it doesn’t make up for the original cheese. 5.2