Download
Home
Top Restaurants
New York Pizzeria
New York Pizzeria
2 East Main Street, Trumansburg, New York
Dave
0.0
Community
8.2
Rated 8.2 based on 7 reviews
Facebook
Twitter
Copy Link
More
0 likes
brent.muni
8/30/25 10:50 PM
About New York Pizzeria
Powered by
288 Yelp Reviews
brent.muni
8/30/25, 10:50 p.m.
7.7
Solid, good undercarage
0 likes
buono
11/18/23, 9:01 p.m.
7.9
Great NY spot
0 likes
stephen.milo
9/2/22, 7:22 p.m.
9.3
I did not know they made pizza this good outside of the immediate New York metropolitan area. This place earns the name New York Pizza with an extremely fine crunch. It looks saucy but it is just right amount and every bit of flavorful that you could hope for. Every one of the five varieties you see on the table was terrific and they need to add more and better hours! Great late lunch though and worth the wait around Trumansville or whatever town we're in. The pesto artichoke just hits different!
0 likes
ed.h1
8/29/21, 12:07 a.m.
8.3
I mean I’m from Buffalo, but this was as good as Joe’s in Manhattan.
0 likes
z.worthington
7/25/20, 7:29 p.m.
7.5
Very good pizza for Upstate NY. Best you’re going to get in the area by far. Sauce was fresh tasting, cheese wasnt too salty or rubbery, dough was thin and encrusted in cornmeal. Crispy and no flop but the dough was a bit tough. Respectable pizza.
3 likes
brendan.w
10/18/19, 5:34 p.m.
8.4
1 like
joshua.rivera
6/22/19, 1:02 a.m.
8.2
Crispy crust, new york style, little greasy. Good pizza in a small town!! Great find.
1 like
Facebook
Twitter
Instagram
YouTube
© 2025 Barstool Sports. All rights reserved.
Terms of Use
Privacy Policy
Content Policy
Contact Us
App Support