New Yorkese

Best pizza in the Denver/Boulder area by a mile.

Excellent! Great sauce and excellent crust…..for Colorado

Rivaling my favorite in Boulder. It’s a treat to get this pie.

Top tier pizza

High price for average pizza. Really greasy but a cheese and pepperoni were on point. Crust was too crusty

From shilo himself #gobuffs

Not great, but not the worst

The crisp of the crust was the only true positive. Sauce was ok and the sausage decent. Way too onion and just didn’t taste right

Fantastic pizza perfect crisp good flavor

extremely legit. zero flop. definitely best i’ve had in CO.

Would I drive an hour for it? Maybe. Is it the best place in Boulder? Definitely

Thin and crispy with minimal flop. The price is a bit steep at 15 a pie. Overall great.

Very solid pizza. The crust is by far the best part of the pie and is delicious. They added too much parmesean cheese which definitely brought down the score. Overall a great pizza.

Solid crust, good dough, texture cheese and sauce is great!

“The longest attack of hiccups lasted 68 years.”

Good pizza. Solid crisp. Could use a little more flavor from the sauce. Would be in the 8’s if so.

almost perfect. light crispy crust that doesn't just flake apart. sauce is excellent.