Top Restaurants

NickyBoy’s Pizza Joint

NickyBoy’s Pizza Joint

143 Franklin Avenue, Nutley, New Jersey

Pizza Review

0 likes

zacv on One Bite Pizza App

zacv

7/21/23 10:55 PM

Thinnny thin with pepperoni. Great taste, I was a little disappointed by the pepperoni distribution. The undercarriage wasn’t too crispy but probably my fault as it had cooled down by the time I got home. The “crust” was delicious and pure crispy cheese.

Order NickyBoy’s Pizza Joint

Hungry? Order right now on Slice

Order now on Slice

Pizza Review

will.sikora18/12/23, 10:21 p.m.

9.3

They are always great to get. The gluten free pizza is a 9.6 but i would rate they’re regular a 9.3. 0 flop, great little pepperonis and the cheese and sauce tastes great. The crust is just a little too crispy. Other than that though a 9.3 pizza.

Pizza Review

hotelfire7/22/23, 6:42 p.m.

6.8

I tried this place again, formally Michael’s as I heard the owners were related to Angeloni’s in West Caldwell and the pizza there was pretty decent. I ordered a cast iron Sicilian and plain round pie-not thinny thinny. The round pie had the same thickness as say Ralphs’s down the street, but sauce and cheese was bland. Crust needed salt and was kind of tasteless. The cast iron Sicilian was a severe let-down, same dough issues as round pie and not very much flavor. Not very good

Pizza Review

michael.stefanelli5/20/23, 3:02 a.m.

7.7

Thinny thin pictured, good but not as good as cousin Angeloni's. Regular pizza solid too. Sauce was just ok. In end, worthy of being in the Nutley rotation.