Order now on Slice
Order Nonna Mia Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
About Nonna Mia Pizza
10 Yelp Reviews
dylan.ray2/10/20, 6:28 p.m.
Bland. No crisp. Good crust Under new ownership new name is “Gerardo’s Pizza and Pasta” .
dennis p.pluth10/29/19, 10:10 p.m.
Like most Long Islanders/New Yorkers I have eaten a lot pizza from a lot of different places; this one of my favorites. Limited to no flop, crispy bottom. A solid NY slice!
larry.h9/14/19, 7:23 p.m.
Plain slice is very good. Nice crispy crust (no flop), with the right amount of cheese and sauce. A little greasy but not enough to complain about. 7.4 BONUS REVIEWS: Sicilian slice was very good as well. Good crisp, nice airy dough. The sauce was so flavorful; I tasted herbs and sauce in every bite. Cheese was a little greasy, but also not enough to complain about. And not too much cheese either. 7.2 Dr. Pepper. Cans and 2 liter bottles available. No fountain soda. (Ps. Great price for a good slice!)
mary.j9/14/19, 7:18 p.m.
Solid slice, the crust is amazing. Sauce had really good flavor. Had some New York flop but nothing crazy. I feel a fresh pie probably would get an even higher review. I will definitely come back.