Nonna's Pizza & Italian Restaurant

My childhood slice. And it’s fire. Could be a tad crispier, but still great.

Very good. Food takes a little long. But it’s something to soothe your hunger.

Margherita w/grilled chicken. Sweet sauce, with an amazing crust/undercarriage. The crust/undercarriage is absolute perfection. Bonus is they did not skimp on the basil. Fantastic pie 🍕

My favorite NJ pizza spot! Finally got what Nonna’s was known for and boom, the best grandma alive I’ve ever had! I like the crust and the sauce is flavorful!

That Nonna slice is fantastic. The crust is crispy and buttery

Great taste but did have significant flop

Nonna’s Grandpa pie

Plain slice: great undercarriage. Nice tangy sauce. A bit soupy in middle but good. Awesome crust! 7.7 Bonus Grandpa slice: good undercarriage. Same tangy sauce. Nice crust. 7.3

Definitely in the high 7s, the sauce is what stands out with this pie. A little on the doughier side if that is what you like 🍕

Hot, crunchy, saucy, fresh. It was perfection.

The crisp is miraculous on these slices. These stiffies also had wonderful sauce and basil components. Lives up to the hype.

There is so much hype around this place and I never hear the end of it as I go to school about two miles away. The pie is quality and well deserving of the praise though. Cheese was very good and texture of the pie was exactly how I believe it should be. I just wish the sauce was better, and the pie was seasoned a bit. Couldn’t see it in the 8-range because of the lack thereof.

Nice thin crust. Great taste.

Good pizza. Would like it a bit more well done but good mid-thick pizza.

This is my second review of Nonnas. I said I’d return to review the Margherita pie and I’m glad I did. Loved the texture and crunch of this one along with the fresh tomatoes. They didn’t skimp on the fresh basil either. The put some effort into the craftsmanship for this one. One of the better margheritas. Give it a try! Big score

Best sauce we’ve had since moving to NJ. Not sure this style would replace our go to’s, but nice for a change up.

Sweet sauce

Large slices. Good sauce. Crazy cheap. Definitely a solid place.

Good sauce. Pie not cut evenly for whatever reason. At a 7.5 this place is still better than the majority of places within the area.

First of all, as far as this pizza game goes, it's good to be back in Jersey. NJ is a level up from some other parts of the North East that I've been traveling and working through. Anyway, Nona's did not disappoint and definitely holds its own amongst some heavy hitters in the area. Thin, crispy,crunchy, savory. Can't go wrong. High scores for the white slice as well. I would eat at Nona's all the time if I lived here.