Nonna's Pizza

Good thin crust, New York style pizza, good undercarriage, I would eat here again.

Beach pizza

Got the Margherita pizza, simply amazing. Sauce was fresh and could tell it wasn’t from a jar. Mozzarella was great and it had the undercarriage to die for and absolutely zero flop. Might be scoring a little high but I’m sure Dave would go high 7s low 8s with this one.

Fine pizza. We ate the whole thing but cheese was off and sauce didn’t have a lot of flavor. The balcony area was a good place to sit and staff was great.

Pizzas come in round or square. We got The square pep and it is hands down one of the best pies I’ve ever had. Owners originally from Jersey. Friendly staff, giving mom and pop, welcoming vibes. Gotta get Dave to this one!!

One bite, everybody knows the rules… Great pizza. Crisp crust. Solid choice.

Very crunchy, awesome sauces and texture. Wonderful pizza!

Great old school pizza shop! You can tell it’s a small family business & the pizza is really good. Crispy thin crust with a solid bite!

It was delicious! Could have had a bit more char but that's just my personal preference. 100% coming back every time we come to the beach. The Christian music sealed the deal. We had the buffalo chicken and a half cheese/pep.

Stopped by June 2025, and petitioned One Bite to add this place because it was criminal that it wasn’t already on there. It’s legit, skip the Mellow Mushroom or any of the other chains and tourist traps in the area. Get this instead.

Good crust. Good cheese quality. Great sauce, I just needed a little more. Overall good pizza. Would definitely eat again.

Great crisp, great flavor! This was a random stop and could not be happier.

Good crisp. No flop. Great flavor. I would eat this regularly if I lived in Gulf Shores.

Pepperoni deep dish. A bit doughy but super awesome workers in there

Unfortunately didn’t grab a photo but the pizza was phenomenal. Got the Abe. Sausage, grilled onions, peppers, red sauce. Crispy crust. Great people inside. This place is great. Glad we tried it. Large pie was $26. Enjoying my leftovers back at my condo now.

The Margarita pizza is the star of the show. The pepperoni was good but a little too greasy and would give it a 7.8. Wife approves this score.

Who would have thought I have to come to Alabama for authentic NY style pizza?!?! What a beautiful pizza Papa Sal makes here! Pizza is delish and the family business is pure love!

Best pizza ever. Real italian New Yorkers! Fresh ingredients. Thin crispy dough

Wonderful service. Great taste and amazing crust!