Nonna's Pizza Tottenville

Very good thing crisp bottom

super thin slice little floppy on the bottom but in a good way, reallyyy good sauce nice and sweet.

Just tried Nonna’s for the first time, waiting for an oil change, and I’m blown away. I’m a boro full of “8+” this one is tops. I grew up near Di Fara, have tried Sally’s Apizza, Delucias, and others. This is up there. It hits every mark on the Dave scale. 9.1. Gasp. Pick your jaw up off the floor.

So this was a nice surprise. Great taste, crisp no flop pizza the way I like it. This was takeout and I was pleasently surprised. I really enjoyed it. I recently moved to the area and this might become my go to neighborhood pizzeria.