NY Pie (Hendersonville)

Hands down the best pizza in Tennessee. Staff is very friendly too! I talked to John at the front the entire time waiting for my pizza. Some flop on the slice but great crunch in the bite. Flavor is incredible. Only pizza stop in TN. Go try it!

Topping is great the box killed the heat. Pizza was cold. You need to have this straight out of the oven. And ask for extra sauce

Very good taste, sauce and cheese combo hit the spot. Nice crust. I like slightly more crunch to the pizza itself, but it was not bad. If there was a negative, it was a little bit greasy. But all in all, it tasted very good.

Anywhere in the northeast it’s a 6.1 Tennessee and their lack of great pizza gives it a volunteer boost.

Pleasantly surprised! Crispy undercarriage and good sauce/cheese marriage

Best Hendersonville pizza. Service is a little surly from the counter guy, but slices get dropped quick and hot to your table. No flop on these two slices.

14” w/extra sauce. Good each visit- good flavor and plenty of toppings. Garlic knots w/marina are a plus.

Very good overall. Was greasy in the middle leavening it a little floppy. The toppings weren’t spread out and focused in the middle.

A little greasy but tasty.

Flop city good crunch. Some oil drip No bad sice

Good char on the bottom, not a lot of flop at all. A lot of grease. Had to dab that off before diving in. Great price for the 18”. Would definitely recommend giving them a shot. Pepperonis had a tiny bit of flavor. Cheese was solid. Sauce had good spices and flavoring. Good sauce to cheese ratio as well. Just wish it wasn’t as greasy as it was.

I had a really difficult time scoring this because...I really liked it but I wanted to be realistic with the score. I ordered a 10" Margherita. It is made NU style with All purpose flour, unlike the original. I devoured this pizza. Crust was airy and crispy. No leoparding because of the style of oven used. Sauce is tangy but not overpowering. Cheese is not fresh mozzarella, but low fat mozzarella... Super satisfied however. Will order again for $10.92. 👍🏼

Flops like a fish outta water, but maintains decent crunch. Needs a little more sauce but overall a good slice, may be king of Hendersonville pizza game.

Stopped in for a couple by the slices. Sriracha chicken and salami with mushroom. Good flop. A little char. Just the right crisp. Best NY style pizza in Hendersonville.

Margarita with extra ricotta. Solid pie. Best I’ve found in the area.

Sicilian this time. Usually not my style, but this one is like eating a pillow.

Good taste. Good crisp. A bit greasy and very messy.

Decided to give it another try, got 2 cheese slices. Much better this time around one of the best tasting cheese slices ive had in this town.

Good slice just nothing that makes it stand out just your average slice