NY Pizza Suprema

Solid but nothing crazy

Rushy vibe and loud atmosphere but good pizza. NY Pizza Suprema New York City Pizza. Top Rated by Dave Portnoy. NY Slice, Sicilian, and Old World Pepperoni Pizza Near Times Square.

Piping hot. Shit is hitting. Solid muzz. No flip. Good sauce.

My expectations here were a little lower - L’Industrie the day before, last stop of the trip, right across from Penn, felt a little touristy…doesn’t matter. Second best slice of the trip, SUPER NICE people, great flavor and lots of options.

I got there late and the only cheese slices they had looked like they had been sitting for a while so I went with the upside down slice. Nice sauce and cheese, crust is pillowy except by the crust. They didn’t heat it up enough so it was only lukewarm. I expected better.

Stopped here following a concert at MSG. Great location. I ordered the pepperoni slice and it was extremely greasy. I needed a few napkins on it. It was scorching hot even after several minutes. However, good crisp and good ingredients!

I didnt like it at all. Too much sauce. Messy.

Lots of sauce which I like. Crispy bottom, not that much cheese. Sauce tasted fresh. Very solid

Lots of sauce, but still good

Great undercarriage and I like the sauce! Very good

Cheese slice was nice and crispy with a perfect tomato sauce. Topping pizzas were lower in quality though

One of the best NYC slice shops Fresh, tomatoey sauce; right amount of cheesy; crispy crust without being burnt Also a decent sized slice

Pizza was solid. I had the cheese and a buffalo chicken ranch. This is solely off of a cheese review. Good hold and solid cheese but the flavor of the sauce was ok in my opinion. Would go again after a game at MSG

Great slice, priced at 4.75, amazing sauce with perfect herb blend, crust was crispy enough, and the cheese was tasty but a bit too sparse, 8/10 would come back after a knicks game

Floopppppy, cheese is delish and sauce is complimentary. Needs char

Burrata slice. That’s some New York flop right there. This one surprised me at how good it was. A thin pie but great distribution of toppings. Fresh basil like Di Fara was a great touch. Loads of choice here.

New York Pizza Suprema - Slice Style: New York * Appearance/Presentation: 4/5 * Notes: classico, grease pool * Taste: 4.7 * Sauce/Cheese/Topping: 4.3/5 * Notes: Oily af but didn’t sacrifice the structure * Dough: 4.8/5 * Notes: Burnt-ish undercarriage but good integrity * Crust: 4.5/5 * Notes: Crunchy * Total Score (25 max.): 22/25 = 8.9/10 - Price (worth it?): $7/slice (eh) - Additional Notes: pricy but quality - Had white/garlic & hot/honey