NY Pizza Suprema

Great flavors, crust is on point! Also tried the upside down Sicilian… loved it!!

Hot Honey slice

Great pizza, tons of options, by the slice is the way to go. Upside down slice was delicious.

Diavola and regular slice

Solid NY slice Upside Down 7.9 Burrata slice 7.5 White w Hot Honey 7.1 Mushroom 7.8

Really good, cheese is very very good. The pepperoni is a 7.5 and the dough it well cooked🫡

Eli’s pepperoni was an 8.4 My bacon chicken ranch was a 7.6 Average is a ranking of 8.

Great tang. Reminds me of Pinos in Brookline, MA

Literally perfection in a bite. Sauce to cheese ratio was perfect and under carriage was thin and crispy. Definitely worth the stop. They are cranking out slices like you wouldn’t believe!

If you’re in NYC, this is a must try! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time!

Fell apart. A lot of grease. Must have caught them on a bad day

Yes I was starving. Yes I forgot to take a picture. Light, thin, crispy, charred. All around a great slice

Good sauce. Cheese had quality. It was a reheat slice so I’d have expected crispier dough but it was still sort of soft. But coming off the train at Penn I’d still do this over most of the other pizza places nearby.

My favorite pizza of all time - I’d be willing to take the train from Baltimore to NYC just to get this pizza and come back - love it