NY Pizza Suprema

Tough start as the construction failed on the fold resulting in a failed flop. Great tasting pizza but more messy and heavy than I like for a NY slice. It’s a standout great tasting slice in midtown Manhattan.

Had two slices , the cheese and supremo (pictured). Great crisp and undercarriage, sauce is a touch sweet but in a complementary way to the tomatoes rather than sickly. Toppings were well balanced, overall worth seeking out in midtown

Its a 9.1 because its great AND it is different. They put grated cheese with the cheese topping. Also the tomato sauce is thicker snd more natural with good quality. Its not brick oven but its great fir what it is.

Very good one the best I have had. Sauce was tasty, A little heavy though.

Wanted to see if it lived up to Dave’s 8.2, and it absolutely did. So much so, that I gave it a true and honest 8.3. Legitimately great slice, no flop, incredible sauce, and look forward to trying everytime I return to MSG

Sauce was a little too sweet, but the crust is on point. Excellent place to grab your first slice coming out of the train station.

Best slice of pep I have ever had

The cheese was way to floppy. Crust was crisp but the rest was just too soft. Threw a meatball slice in for context and it was actually really good. Still floppy but good meat.

What a crisp!

Nice crunch and no flop. Little greasy. Hot AF. Burnt my whole mouth. The tomato Sicilian has a nice fluff and crunch as well. I give that a 7.9. Very enjoyable after a SZA concert at the garden

Colossal slices. Have been here many times but under estimated the girth of these slices and how good they are prior to midnight. 8.9 New York, but probably 9’s locally in central to north jersey. Try the mushroom hot honey. Puts a little tickle in the spincter.

Very solid

Very very good pizza had the chicken bacon ranch man o man can’t go wrong there !

Great crisp. Great undercarriage. Not greasy Excellent slice