Great crunch, sweet sauce, great slice overall
Order now on Slice
Order NY Pizza Suprema
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
fratrick12/27/21, 9:51 p.m.
Thin crust, great sauce and poppin cheese. Big slice but def one of the better ones
kevin.price11/15/21, 9:57 p.m.
Upside down Sicilian and damn what a light pillowy amazing crunchy slice robust seasoned chunky sauce topped with grated cheese sets this off! The cheese pull from underneath is stuff of legends and the taste of the crunchy crust is legendary.
daniel.jackson310/14/21, 10:45 p.m.
The sign out front claimed "#1 slice in New York" so I don't know how you pass up that opportunity. Unfortunately I really doubt that's true, although it was a really quality slice with good crisp and solid tasting sauce. Right outside MSG/Penn & would absolutely stop again on the way to the stadium/train. Specialty slices looked decent, but very expensive. I guess that's what you're gonna get out of that area
tommyg68810/14/21, 9:47 p.m.
Stopped here before the Blueshirts game. Fresh out of oven all I can say I wow. Great crust zero flop. Thin but not cracker thin. On the saucy side but I like that. Perfect amount of delicious cheese.
zzpizzadog10/9/21, 10:00 p.m.
This is New York Pizza. Big slices, crisp crust that folds, gooey cheese, loud, wonderful. Perfect amount of sauce, great variety of different slices. My score is so high because everything about the place from the tin pans to the slices in the window you point at to the men in blue mauling slices between patrols just tastes like New York and New York just tastes like pizza.
socaltw10/3/21, 5:54 p.m.
Starting a day of pizza reviews with the trusty dusty Pizza Suprema right next to MSG. This is the first place a brought T to in NYC! Once again it didn’t disappoint !!
ascher10/3/21, 5:07 p.m.
The cheese was incredible. Great crispy undercarriage and the crust may have been the best part.