Order now on Slice
Order NY Pizza Suprema
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
About NY Pizza Suprema
2,400 Yelp Reviews
joseph.cummings112/30/22, 1:30 a.m.
Very very good pizza had the chicken bacon ranch man o man can’t go wrong there !
based_horse12/9/22, 7:51 p.m.
I stopped here for some quick pizza while in the city and to see if it merited its One Bite score. They were very busy, but they operate like an assembly line and they constantly have slices in the oven popping out for the next customer. As for the regular slice, it was thin and had zero flop. In addition, every bite guaranteed you a crunch regardless of where you bit it. The sauce also has some tomato chunks in it so if you like that, it's a plus. I think the slice overall is a very standard NYC slice in style, but above average in its execution. The taste specifically is fine, however nothing that stands out. While it is fresh, it's a very typical slice but with pretty good dough and structural integrity. The other slice I got is their Fra Diavolo. It's topped with mildly spicy pepperoni imported from Italy and also provides a lot of crunch. It's good, however I would have liked the pepperoni to be spicier and for there to be more cheese. I would rate that slice a 7.7. The regular gets an 8.0 primarily for the zero flop/crisp it achieves, but the taste is a bit lacking for anything higher.
jake.enea5112/9/22, 5:55 a.m.
Tried the plain and BBQ chicken slices. Great crunch and a savory sauce with lots of herbs. Restaurant had a cool old-fashioned pizzeria atmosphere. Authentic NY pizza at its core.
steve.w1312/3/22, 2:04 a.m.
I thought the pizza could have used more crisp. Sauce was on point and cheese was delicious. I also got an upside down and it had a soapy taste… I would recommend but currently not the 8.2 that Dave gave it.
anthony.pizza311/11/22, 12:49 a.m.
Sweet sauce (good) Cheese is just the right amount salt (good) Not much of a flop (good)
johnconquest10/10/22, 6:13 p.m.
Pretty good pizza. Nice crunch. Worth the price, but maybe a dollar lower. Definitely a one or two time visit
alex.tarnava9/19/22, 7:59 p.m.
Got the cheese with their homemade mozzarella, add basil, cooked well done. Have hit this place every time I’m in NY for the last decade.
apizzapie.guy8/14/22, 1:54 a.m.
Solid Classic Ny Slice! I base all my pizza reviews off of this place. This is the Sliced Italian Meatball. Really good toppings undercarriage, crisp and sauce. If your in the area it’s a must stop.
rushfan-duhpizzareviewdude8/11/22, 9:53 p.m.
Really good sauce. Very good execution. Top notch. Solid crust and crunch. Taste excellent but not outstanding. Slightly sweet and a hint of spices