NY Pizza Suprema

If you’re in NYC, this is a must try! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time!

Fell apart. A lot of grease. Must have caught them on a bad day

Yes I was starving. Yes I forgot to take a picture. Light, thin, crispy, charred. All around a great slice

Good sauce. Cheese had quality. It was a reheat slice so I’d have expected crispier dough but it was still sort of soft. But coming off the train at Penn I’d still do this over most of the other pizza places nearby.

My favorite pizza of all time - I’d be willing to take the train from Baltimore to NYC just to get this pizza and come back - love it

Sauce good

The sauce is the winner on this pizza. Overall amazing slice

This pizza was good! So close to being an 8.1… I’m a sauce guy but the sauce totally reminded me of margherita pizza sauce, just so sweet. The cheese melted off kinda easy, the slice was steaming hot so it’s kinda my fault lol. All around a good pizza, was just so hard to score.

Really good looking pizza and you could tell great ingredients. Just too sweet for me. If you like your pizza sweet this is your spot

They gave it crispy which was great, but had a lot of flop and grease. Lifted it up and it fell in two. Sauce lacked a little seasoning for my taste. Crust was really good.

pretty mid. the chicken is the only thing that makes it decent. marg tastes weird and is overcheesed in that way that only someone succumbing to the average american’s cheese obsessed tastebuds could appreciate

Their sauce is something tasty special

I love this place. It’s the perfect example of a New York slice. Great char on the undercarriage, delicious and crispy crust, sweet and tangy sauce, great ratio of cheese. There was a bit of flop this time around, but it can be ignored. It’s great and worth going to the area for if you want one of the best slices.

Fantastic margarita slice, sausage slice was awesome, cheese slice fell short. Tasty sauce but little bit much on that cheese slice. Won’t be able to get over that marg for a minute tho.

Taste was good! But had a big flop and fell apart. Pizza shown in the picture is two sausage slices! Plus the atmosphere was nuts and crazy busy.

It was a good pie

Sausage slice was decent, 7.3 Fra Diavolo Sicilian was a much better slice, 7.8. Average and rounded up gives a 7.6.