O Sole Mio NY

Not a lot of flavor, which is a shame because I really, really wanted to like this slice. The sauce is good, but leaves a little bit to be desired. crust is wet but dry at the same time and not in a good way. Cheese is decent.

Really disappointing slice on flavor and freshness. It was not charred but burnt tasting which was a complete distraction from any else

Gone downhill. This is suppose to be Well done and greasy cheesy doughy mess

The garlic knots to the bread to pizza great experience

Pizza

Score would’ve been higher if it had more flavor. Tasteless slice

Above average long island pizza. Little burnt undercarriage. Good cheese to sauce ratio

Pizza!

Good football pizza

Best sauce around town

Good solid pizza

Crust is nice and crunchy, kind of greasy, slight flop, flavored enough... doesn't jump out at you but makes it tasty.... could have more sauce... cheese is real good, super solid slice

It’s funny... I’ve been here before as well a bunch of times... but now that I’m doing all these reviews and just getting the gold standard slice instead of toppings or specialty slices, I’m really seeing what’s up. So, I thought for sure this would score higher... See what happens when you take the meatball or pepperoni out of the equation?? Ay oh... we get the 6.3. Floppy, doughy...nothing special... nothing stands out at all. Not bad, just super average... well maybe slightly below... I consider 7’s average. But they do good business... specialty slices are good. 🤷🏻‍♂️

About a solid as they come👍🏻

Good slice. flaky crust, lots of cheese, dynamite sauce, very floppy, some cheesy grease. Overall not bad, but not worth all the hype