Ohio Pie Co

First look, solid undercarriage, good crisp. Sauce has a little tang to it—nice touch. Ordered a small pie while waiting on some paczkis from Donut Land. This place has potential. I’ll be back to give it another go. Solid effort.

The crust and cheese are genuinely spectacular. I was not a huge fan of the sweetness of the sauce, but it was still a great pie! It’s a WEIRD pie too, and not in a bad way! It’s thick, yet it’s super light and crispy. It’s similar to Detroit style, but it’s definitely its own thing. Great staff and a cool neighborhood vibe. Really glad I checked it out.

Great Ohio style pizza with a good undercarriage. The sauce is on the sweeter side.

Tried the heartburner. Serious amount of toppings. Loved the garlic oil. Very tasty and well cooked.

Very reminiscent of Pizza Hut crust. Nice crisp on the crust, doughy center. Sauce is different, a bit sweet. Not bad but different from the other guys. Generous toppings. I’d come back.

I had to sit with this one for a few days before committing to a final score. It’s definitely my style. A thicker pan pizza with a sweet sauce, cup and char pepperoni, crumbled sausage and topped with a garlic sauce. It’s like if Detroit pizza and Buffalo pizza had a baby and it’s one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had in my life. My only gripe is that it’s cut into squares but that’s a minor gripe. Great crunch, great soft dough, great taste in every bite and a great atmosphere inside (hardcore music and a free video game arcade). I initially had this in the high eights but after a lot of soul searching I decided to put it in the nines and I think it deserves to be there. It’s not going to be for everyone but it’s absolutely for me. I loved it. Get the cookies, too.

Little thicker than what I usually prefer but it still has amazing crisp and a solid undercarriage. House made ranch and “Ohio style” cookies are a must when visiting. Love the sauce on top as well, it adds a nice visual touch that most pizza places don’t care to add.

Absolutely not in line with the local ratings. Wow! I'm astonished people have this as an 8+. This is typical chain pizza with provolone.

Good pizza. Pro- consistency, price, taste. Con- sweet sauce (I don’t prefer sweet sauces).

Good basic pie. Sweet sauce.

Best Pizza in NE Ohio! Fantastic ingredients and flavors. Maybe best in Ohio. You have had others you think are good, now have this.

Good sweet sauce. Crispy crust and good quality cheese. Very solid pizza.

Great taste. Sweet sauce. Ordered mine well done and it wasn’t super crispy…but the taste more than made up for it. Worth a try for sure!

Far drive for us so eating lukewarm still amazing. Nice airy dough cooked very well. Sauce on the top and just all around a good quality pizza. My sons gave it a 9.3 and 8.3 and my wife gave it a 8.5. Worth the trip.

Sweet sauce. But so good.

Breakfast pizza.

Pizza seemed dry. Cheese was weak. Sauce was sweet but just falls off a cliff fast.

Very high quality ingredients on this pizza. It's a little thicker, but the crust is very light and airy. So that you know, not a traditional pizza as it has a garlic oil on the crust and they drizzle the sweet tomato sauce on the top. The sweet sauce is very good and this pie would have got a higher score if I had had more of it. Unfortunately, there were only drips on mine and I could only taste it every third bit or so.