Old School Pizzeria

This is one of those iconic pizzas that you always remember the flavor and crave every once in a while. The dough and cheese are fresh. It’s not too sloppy or floppy for a big pizza. The staff already greets you with a smile, and there is pool while you wait. If you like a sweet sauce, this is your place.

I’ve heard so many good reviews about this place but every time I tried to order they was closed. I finally got a chance to try it and OMG was it amazing!!! I don’t throw around 9’s just anywhere. I was a bit shocked by the price of $20 for a pizza in Preston County of all places but after the first bite you can see why. You can tell the high quality ingredients used in this pizza. I’ve had pizza from all across the country and it’s kinda like NY & Chicago had a baby and made this. Sweet sauce with a rich cheese taste is the best way to describe it. And the crust reminds you of a deep fried doughnut! Had a 10 minute chat with the owner who runs this place out of a rundown school house he’s fixing up. This place probably isn’t ever going to make it on Prez’s list because of its location and I seriously doubt it’s his style because of the sweetness of the sauce but I feel he would give it a respectable 7.8

Probably one of the bests crusts I’ve ever had. Sauce is a sweeter style sauce. First time I ever had ground pepperoni on a pizza. Cheese had really good flavor. I think if it had regular sliced pepperoni that would crisp up in the oven would put this over an 8. All in all a really good pie.

Amazing pizza, everything’s homemade and you can tell it’s made with fresh ingredients. Cash only spot. The name “Old School Pizzeria” is cool because it’s in a old high school turned pizza place. Family recipe from the 60’s. Gotta give it a try! 20 minutes from Morgantown. Worth the drive.