Original Brooklyn Pizzeria & Restaurant

Great pie, very good cheese to sauce ration, crispy, little flop.

Easily the best in the area. A little more chees than I prefer, which made it a little oily. However, the undercarriage, crispness, and flavor was on point. And the staff was super nice, combined with an old school vide, make this pizzeria the go to.. Add a few points for you cheese lovers. But either way, great slice!

No straws

Everybody in town doesn’t even think about this place, this place is OS for life, straight class, slice is thin like megan fox in transformers 1 , another minute in the oven its over an 8.5

Got the Sicilian and it was really very good

Thin crispy and really good similar to Frank Pepe’s

I hate to leave unfavorable reviews but this was really not great at all. First off, 2 slices and a small drink was $13 cash. That’s wild. The square slice is insanely thick and doughy and the cheese is cold and congealed and not even cooked. The plain slice is floppy and oily. Maybe I caught them on an off day but only a bite taken out of each and that was more than enough.

Nice people. Slice was decent but it was very flimsy and not firm

Doughy and sauce leaves a lot to be desired.

Big dinner of mine some may say, but not too impressed

Ay oh, you wanna talk about pet peeves. Don’t put “Brooklyn” or “Original” in your name when your pizza place is on Long Island unless it’s friggin phenomenal tasting… This pizza looks good enough. Score wise, as you can see… it’s just ok. Taste is fine… but cmon… Brooklyn? Uhm, no. That’s a review.

Bought a pie from original Brooklyn pizza it’s a 10 thin and crispy. I definitely recommend this place

A very solid slice of pizza. Nothing to write home about, but I don’t think anyone will be disappointed.

Original Brooklyn Pizzeria & Restaurant Rating - 7.8/10 Good thin pizza. Cheese overload.

Buffalo chicken slice

Great NY flop, very thin with a crispy crust, phenomenal cheese and little sauce

Above average not bad

Really good slice