Pagliai's Pizza

A Mankato icon since the 60’s tons of cheese and sausage is great season and flavor. Your classic pizza joint. You don’t go here for a “pretty looking pizza” but one thrown together. It’s worth the hour to hour half drive from the cities.

Delicious “bar pizza” with the perfect balance of cheese to crust to sauce ratio. The best south of the cities no frills pie around!

Great bar pie! Lots of sauce. No flop. Full arm cheese pull. The crust was thin and just needed…more. It’s good but it’s missing flavor

Large pepperoni.. decent tavern style. Crust was crisper than I expected with the conveyer belt cooker, but at the same time, this is nothing to hoot and holler over

Best sauce in the state

Best pizza in Southern Minny, if not in all the land of 10,000 lakes! Crust is crisp, sauce is just right with a little tang and when it meets the cheese…amazing. This place also has amazing hot poorboys and that’s coming from my pal Pete, toughest critic this side of the Mississippi. Btw, Pagliai’s is pronounced (PollyEyes)

Crust was chewy, no sauce.

Good pizza and real solid spaghetti dinner!

Even though it was a tad undercooked, too much sauce for my liking, and they didn’t take the time to get the bubbles out while it was cooking, it is still by far my favorite pizza place in Mankato. Amazing pie

Was really good

Perfectly cooked

This pizza has more flavor and spice than my marriage ever did

One bite everyone knows the rules. The pizza is not flimsy very firm solid pizza, little greasy. Solid ingredients create a good taste but it is slight too saucy for my taste and the cheese was pulling off with every bite. Good tasting pizza but not an easy eat.

Arguably the best pizza in Mankato

Best in town.

Good pizza. Total football pizza.