Order now on Slice
Order Papa Joe's
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
About Papa Joe's
87 Yelp Reviews
rms171/15/21, 11:37 p.m.
Good flavor. Too much oil/grease. Sauce is plain but all comes together for a good central pa slice.
tim.vaz12/12/20, 1:42 a.m.
Good solid pizza. Very greasy but good flavor and crust. Bonus review on the Chicken Bacon Ranch slice 8.2
matt.ney12/9/20, 11:59 p.m.
Good look..lots of flop, not too greasy...flavor of sauce is excellent with slight tang. doughy but not chewy crust. This is a good comination of the main ingredients with cheese and sauce in balance. I would order this before others in the area.
stevieslice8/4/20, 5:05 p.m.
Not my type of pizza. The plain slice is heavy w cheese and just heavy. Just not a well crafted pie.
tyler.vajda1/13/20, 1:59 a.m.
Best grandma style pizza in Harrisburg area. Sauce to cheese ratio is on point. Weekly spot.
todd.bosley8/18/19, 11:46 p.m.
Grandma slice is better than standard cheese. Too much cheese for my liking. Grandma 8.1
hashtaggis7/30/19, 10:09 p.m.
I've been in here when both the regular cheese slice and Gramma slice were 8.5 all day. Unfortunately, today when I am reviewing it, was not that day. To be honest it wasn't an 8 today, but both were still a solid 7.7
ryan.davis185/29/19, 5:24 p.m.
Slightly above average, enjoyed it the first time I came better, this experience I was given reheated slices that were probably sitting too long. Still gets a 6.8 on their old slice, so in general, the pizza is good here! It's a 7.8 when it's fresh.
n8885/10/19, 3:25 p.m.
Left is the Grandmas Style: more of a flaky crust. Good crispy. Excellent Sauce. Plenty of cheese. Bit of tang. Right is traditional Pepperoni: Crust was excellent but the cheese was a bit runny. I like the cheese a little more cooked like the Grandmas Slice is. Grandmas: 8.1 Traditional: 6.8
mrpizzaofpa4/18/19, 4:30 p.m.
Joes: Original- solid crust - one of the better I’ve had in a while. Cheese was salty, aged, sauce a bit milder and bland. Decent football slice. 7.1/10 Sicilian: Bit doughy still in some parts yet the sauce seemed different and much better than original. Cheese similar saltiness. Great slice. 7.6/10 Grandmas: now, Joes is one of the 5-6 places in the 15 mile area I know makes this pie. It’s solid. The sauce is Similar to Sicilian yet a bit oilier. Great grandmas slice. Amazing crust if you get it cooked just right. 7.8/10 Overall - 7.6/10 to Joes!
michael.brisbane2/27/19, 4:37 p.m.
Pretty good Buff Chick slice but Sicilian is top notch. Cowboy Pizza steals the show.
alex.deering10/8/18, 8:37 p.m.
Good pizza. Not too filling. A little greasy and salty but overall good flavor good service and nice crunchy crust.