Papa Joe's

Great sauce with a little flop!

Not a bad standard cheese pizza by any means but the grandma style from this place is the way to go. This pizza had good flavor but it’s pretty basic.

One of the best around Harrisburg. Great looking pie, slices have a little flop, great blend of sauce and cheese, and crust tastes great. There is definitely a difference between a fresh pie and slices, so go with the fresh pie if you want the best experience. Try the grandma, too!

We tried three slices here. A traditional cheese pizza slice, Buffalo Chicken, and their grandma pizza. First reaction to the cheese pizza is it had too much flop; however, the cheese, sauce and crust crunch were on point. Overall their classic cheese pizza is a solid 7.1. Their grandma pizza was very crispy, no flop, a great slice… 7.6. Finally their buffalo chicken. Good flavor, crunch crust, slight flop but expected with heavy toppings. Classic 7.5.

Everyone says you have to get the granma so I did. A little floppy and greesy but awesome taste.

Big flop, but still a slight crisp. Pretty greasy. Cheese is average, but sauce has a nice tang to it. Good crispy crust.

Good flavor. Too much oil/grease. Sauce is plain but all comes together for a good central pa slice.

Good solid pizza. Very greasy but good flavor and crust. Bonus review on the Chicken Bacon Ranch slice 8.2

Good look..lots of flop, not too greasy...flavor of sauce is excellent with slight tang. doughy but not chewy crust. This is a good comination of the main ingredients with cheese and sauce in balance. I would order this before others in the area.

Lower quality cheese takes over.

Not my type of pizza. The plain slice is heavy w cheese and just heavy. Just not a well crafted pie.

Best grandma style pizza in Harrisburg area. Sauce to cheese ratio is on point. Weekly spot.

Grandma slice is better than standard cheese. Too much cheese for my liking. Grandma 8.1

I've been in here when both the regular cheese slice and Gramma slice were 8.5 all day. Unfortunately, today when I am reviewing it, was not that day. To be honest it wasn't an 8 today, but both were still a solid 7.7

Slightly above average, enjoyed it the first time I came better, this experience I was given reheated slices that were probably sitting too long. Still gets a 6.8 on their old slice, so in general, the pizza is good here! It's a 7.8 when it's fresh.

Left is the Grandmas Style: more of a flaky crust. Good crispy. Excellent Sauce. Plenty of cheese. Bit of tang. Right is traditional Pepperoni: Crust was excellent but the cheese was a bit runny. I like the cheese a little more cooked like the Grandmas Slice is. Grandmas: 8.1 Traditional: 6.8

Joes: Original- solid crust - one of the better I’ve had in a while. Cheese was salty, aged, sauce a bit milder and bland. Decent football slice. 7.1/10 Sicilian: Bit doughy still in some parts yet the sauce seemed different and much better than original. Cheese similar saltiness. Great slice. 7.6/10 Grandmas: now, Joes is one of the 5-6 places in the 15 mile area I know makes this pie. It’s solid. The sauce is Similar to Sicilian yet a bit oilier. Great grandmas slice. Amazing crust if you get it cooked just right. 7.8/10 Overall - 7.6/10 to Joes!

Pretty good Buff Chick slice but Sicilian is top notch. Cowboy Pizza steals the show.

Good pizza. Not too filling. A little greasy and salty but overall good flavor good service and nice crunchy crust.