Papa Roni's Pizza & Ice Cream

One of the better spots locally. Still kind of a basic Ohio slice, but pretty flavorful. Crust is a bit bland. Sauce and cheese are great.

Large pepperoni to go. Mediocre at best. Huge flop, canned sauce if I had to guess, cheese blend was slightly unappetizing, and the crust is similar to that of Papa John's. This pizza was clearly undercooked, but I don't think even well done it would be anything more than average at best. Overall, nothing about this pizza makes me want to try it again. 4.9 because they seem like nice people and give you free popcorn. I don't know who eats a pizza like this and says it's great, but I feel bad for them.

Good football pizza. Not too much sauce. The crust needs a little more crunch and flavor. Love the cheese and the crispy pepperonis. It’s in the 7’s cause I love the customer service. The person that answered the phone was super nice. The delivery driver was so pleasant, they even gave a bag of popcorn for the kids. Overall good pizza. Great experience

This pizza excellent. I’m not sure which is better, their crust or sauce. Some of the best I’ve had of each. Not overly greasy and only a slight flop. My only critique would be the cheese. It’s good, but not my favorite style or blend. Still good though.

Not a lot of Crunch in the crust. The Flavor is there, and the crunch of the mini pepperonis is a good touch.