Papa's Tomato Pies

A delicious pie with a lot of crunch . I can eat a whole pie easily. The sauce is really solid.

One of my all time favorites, also located down the street from delorenzo which is just as good, between those two..favorite of all time

Got the mustard pizza... Pretty good, nothing special. Maybe should’ve gone with the regular but definitely overhyped.

Mustard a little over powering, but still very good. Overall good pizza.

Great crisp and perfect amount of cheese. Very tangy sauce. Solid

Ultra thin pizza about as thin as the detectives dick in Deuce Bigalow

AMAZING!

This is a true gem in the middle of New Jersey. Great crisp, sweet sauce and dough. It is nearly perfect.

Good taste and a great crust.

We liked the sweet sauce, nice crispy crust, gotta get it right out of oven next time! Goes good with Yuengling

Sauce is too sweet and cheese is a little cheap tasting. Still good.

Thin, crispy crust. No flop Frankie! Great Sauce!!

Delicious and nutritious

iiYbi.com Reviews! Alright Frankie! So today went to Papa’s Tomatoe Pies. Wow great pizza! A lot of history at the place it’s def a must try. Worth driving 2 hours to try. Sauce is delicious and pizza is very crispy.

Great crunch, great tang. Personally think this is better than De Lorenzos

Great sauce and cheese, thin and crispy crust with no flop. My crust was a little too hard in spots though. Still very good.

This pizza is damn delicious! Crunchy crust, sauce is the main feature. Enjoy!

Really great crisp, nice sweet tomato sauce! Great pizza