About Papa's Tomato Pies
358 Yelp Reviews
mikeyeggs5/26/23, 9:21 p.m.
Didn’t know what to expect when I ordered the mustard pie but damn it was great. So crispy and delicious with a hint of mustard that wasn’t overbearing. Took me 45 minutes from Marlboro to get here and that’s why this score is in the 9’s
hopalongcasadeeech5/17/23, 8:38 p.m.
We ordered a mustard pie with sausage and a pie with mushrooms. Crisp, charred crust, cheese to sauce ratio is on point. Highly recommend Papa's. It is magical to say the least. And if you're on the fence about a mustard pie...just do it, you won't be disappointed!
kb_eats_pizza4/23/23, 6:25 p.m.
Thin, crispy, fantastic flavors. Worth the road trip! A few slices weren’t as well-done as the others and that made a huge difference, need the crunch for a pie like this!
tyler.klinsky4/4/23, 6:33 p.m.
Good flop crispy and good taste. One of the best in Jersey for sure. Water tasted like melted snow
rustyd3/14/23, 6:15 p.m.
EXCELLENT Pizza. Great flavor. Nice Crust. Cooked perfectly. Highly Recommended!!!
jeff.erdman3/13/23, 11:09 p.m.
The Italian, sausage broc Robb, garlic excellent crust abs what a good flavor pizza
ken.liu22/11/23, 2:45 a.m.
I’m gonna give it the 8.9 that Dave was gonna give it after getting a fresh pie. The dough is firm, but amazingly, it follows through when you chew it. If you’re a tomato lover I’d pay the extra $1 for extra tomatoes. Oh, and with this one, you don’t get that greasy, guilty feeling you usually get after eating pizza. Amazingly light, but so full of flavor at the same time. Not 8.3, not 8.6, but a solid 8.9
anewyorkerinthelou12/30/22, 6:10 p.m.
The mustard pie flavor is really interesting, and my family preferred it over the tomato pie, but both were excellent. Mustard pie: 8.8 Tomato pie: 8.5
rich.dott12/27/22, 10:20 p.m.
Worth a 50 min drive but not an hour drive. Pizza was great; not excellent.
kim.tomlinson12/27/22, 10:17 p.m.
Tomatoes are super fresh and prevalent in this pizza. Great crunch on the crust too!
matt.soffer12/27/22, 4:49 p.m.
Premier crisp, great undercarriage, solid cheese to sauce ratio. Zero flop. Sauce didn’t quite have the zip to push the score higher
brooklyn.joe.in.jersey12/22/22, 3:56 a.m.
Top shelf crust and undercarriage. Quality ingredients. Unique taste, especially the mustard pie. Not far off from a 9.1.
andres.ferradans12/2/22, 7:46 p.m.
Alright alright alright,this is what Im talking about! Divine crust!! Sauce on the tangy side dont love it but I can see people liking it, it is just my preference, cheese ratio perfect
z.worthington11/13/22, 7:24 p.m.
110 years this place has been slinging Trenton style Tomato Pie. Dough was super thin and crispy from first bite to the last. Ratios of dough sauce and chese was right on the money, and the sauce is just ripe tomatoes, fresh and vibrant red with a slight natural sweetness. Very tasty pizza.