About Papa's Tomato Pies
241 Yelp Reviews
melissa.lynne5/30/20, 7:39 p.m.
We got the basic and the mustard. Crust was great, good sauce, cheese basic. Just needed something to give it a slightly better flavor. Trying the mustard pizza was just something different to try.
kip.nuesch5/16/20, 7:26 p.m.
30 min later review...Sweet sauce, great crisp, chewy crust....don't feel like ass after eating
davin.moskal5/14/20, 4:14 p.m.
Talk about a beautiful pie. Lovely crunch mixed with an even sauce to cheese ratio. Pretty much melts in your mouth while the sauce offers a perfect amount of tang that you’ll tell your grandkids about.
eliyahu.kheel5/5/20, 5:45 p.m.
Another excellent pie. Not nearly as crispy or well done as De Lorenzo's. But absolutely amazing still.
corey5eager3/29/20, 9:01 p.m.
Super crispy crust, super tomatoey sauce. Well done without the char. Preferred plain to the slices I had with toppings
danie3/29/20, 3:58 p.m.
Crispy crust, tough to fold, a little too saucy for my taste, but a solid slice overall
paul.franzoni13/27/20, 11:42 p.m.
Pupas tomatoes. Very very good pizza. Ask for it well done. Make sure to get it hut out of the oven, as our leader David said, this pizza is in the high 8s fresh out of the oven, low 8s if you’re getting pickup or delivery. Pupas tomatoes
wyatt.barlow3/25/20, 11:28 p.m.
The pizza was solid. We’re thinking it was sitting for about 15 minutes before we got there. Overall a good slice- the dollops of tomato and the well done crust were definitely the stars of the show.
apiewelldone3/15/20, 5:11 p.m.
First time trying a Trenton tomato pie. Very good. Different than any pie I’ve had before. Nice and crispy with good flavor.
t-rex.pizza3/14/20, 5:14 p.m.
The crisp I think registered on the Richter Scale! Amazing! Flavor obviously on point, a little oily, but that was expected with the tomato topping. Worth the 10 min drive off 95.
sagar.shah13/14/20, 4:52 p.m.
Drove a hour because of Dave, wasn't disappointed in the slightest. Great pizza.
matthew.beatty3/14/20, 4:30 a.m.
First time eating a tomato pie and I will have to say it is one of the best pizzas I ever had. Walked in and met Mike. He was just like he was when he was making a fresh pie for the presidente.
ebermorse3/9/20, 11:09 a.m.
Great sauce, great cheese, nice char, super thin, minimal flop, awesome pizza
paulie.pizza3/8/20, 11:14 p.m.
The tomato did not disappoint. Very fresh and seasoned minimally. Cheese is on the bottom and not salty. Crust had very good crisp and the pie overall was a good thickness. Room temperature slice 2 hours later was great. Worth checking out.
apjr2/29/20, 1:33 a.m.
We got a plain pie and mustard. Mustard is uniquely good! Dave is not wrong.
pizzaguy420692/27/20, 11:29 p.m.
OMG This is the best pizza in Jersey.The sauce is AWESOME the dough is fresh and the employees were SO NICE they even let me go in the back!and the cheese is great!