Papa's Tomato Pies

Simply spectacular.

Absolutely incredible. The pinnacle of a tomato pie. Tart and addicting, the crust almost tastes like a buttered cracker? With a hint of char. Never had anything quite like it. Awesome hometown vibes inside as well, BYOB and vintage Tiffany lights.

Great margarita pie

Best of the best. This is the pizza you are looking for.

Very good. floppy in the center but great sauce and crust

Excellent slice! No flop! Great sauce!

i’ll be surprised if it gets much better than this. mustard pie is an absolute gem

The shire amount of sauce glopped on top knocks it down for me. Just my preference. The crust is incredible though. Sauce has a sweet taste to it

Good pizza cheese and sauce were not even distributed. One bite would be just sauce and the next would be just cheese. A lot of grease drips out while you eat.

Lives up to the hype! Solid tomato sauce and appearance, but the cheese and crust leave just a bit to be desired

Drove about 90 minutes to try this pizza and we were not disappointed. This area of New Jersey is known for their tomato pie. It’s more dollops of sweet sauce than an entire base of sauce. Crust was very crispy with no flop, and this is right up my alley. Definitely recommended to try at least once.

My family loved it! Thin and crispy, zero flop. I like a saucy pizza so not really my type. The bites that had sauce were very good!

Great pizza, a first for me trying a pizza with mustard on the bottom, the toppings the tomatoes sauce on top. It was a great environment. Undercarriage could be a little more crispy, but the pizza crunched when biting unto it. Enjoyed the small family old school Italian feel inside. Was great service and cost was more than affordable.

Best Tomato Pie great sauce great flavor.