Pappalardo's Pizza Cove

A good local slice. Nothing jumps out around you about it. Good sauce to cheese ratio. Nice foldable slice without being floppy. Perfect a party if ordering a couple pies.

Dry. Needs more sauce. Below average.

Regular slice and and vodka chicken. I was hungry.

Crust and sauce tasted good, but too much cheese made it floppy and greasy.

Bland slice not nearly enough sauce going on

One of the best slices I have had in a while. Cheese tasted fresh sauce was a little better than mid but the crust was perfect. Also the workers were very friendly overall a great slice.

I’ve had better……

Forgot to take photo of pizza but the cheese and sauce was fire but the crust was kinda disappointing

Nice crunch and right cheese to sauce ratio

Sauce tasted like it was straight out of a can. Crust very plain and “dry”

Chicken Parmesan slice, which was huge.

Very good

Good crust . Nice amount of cheese. Sauce needs little more bite and more sauce on pie. Friendly service. Great 4.99 lunch special during the week. 2 slices and 16 oz soda Mon to Fri. Enjoy !!

Pappalardo’s, big time flop, crust and pizza is very doughy, which is no bueno, sauce is good, no grease, I had this pizza awhile ago and it used to be a lot better, not sure what happened..The Regular is a 5.9, The Buffalo is 5.8

Holy fuck is this good. How is this place rated so low. The crust has some serious crisp, the sauce has a sweet tomato flavor and the cheese is bangin. This is my 36th review, i’m a seasoned vet! If you get the chance, give it a try.

This is a NEIGHBORHOOD. PIZZERIA. Everyone is treated like family. Also, the cheese and sauce are tastier than almost any place else you’ll find. Definitely worth a stop in. Say hey to Joey!!

A Massapequa legend, sauce has nice flavor and very cheesy, crust thicker than normal Long Island pizza but something is missing. The missing ingredient is a belly full of alcohol this is classic late night fair that doesn’t seem that great in the middle of the afternoon.

Found this after a best of Long Island review. The slice was very good. Not as good as I had expected considering the “fame” they had been given. Still it was definitely worth the money and is worth trying if you’re a pizza fan and nearby. Strange name though.