Patsy's Pizzeria

Light, crispy, great sauce, great cheese, could do without the basil

Excellent excellent pizza with its unique crust and sweet sauce.

So yummy!

Very good. The amount of oil was on point, sauce definitely homemade, and just the right amount of cheese. Crust was a tad bit too burnt for my liking but very solid slice.

Great slice, nice char flavor.

Best to let this margarita pie cool down a bit before eating so the flavors can come out. Crust is thin and crispy around the outside. Sauce is decent and cheese is perfect.

Great pizza sauce/cheese ratio was a little sauce heavy, but overall great. Basil makes it really good.

The crust was some of the best we’ve ever had. Unfortunately, the pie sat in the box and we could tell. Little to no stretch on the cheese and we arrived 2-3 minutes before the stated ready time. Great sauce, thin crust, and went down really easily. Would likely improve if eaten in house and not to-go/delivery.

Woah, this place is excellent. Sauce is sweet and crust is light and soft but no flop

The 9.1 is for the pizza on the left (Old Fashioned Square) their traditional on the right is very good at a 8.4

Too much flop but other than that, great pizza

Not the best crust. Sorta like cardboard. But the sauce and pepperoni where great.

Had the square pie with pepperoni, sausage, and meatball. Super fresh ingredients. Crisp, airy, crust. Probably my second favorite pizza in NYC.

Dave was right, this is an absolutely fucking fantastic pizza.

Uneven sauce / cheese distribution. Dough was alright. Basil on top wasn’t doing anything for me. Decent taste tho

Well done old fashion pepperoni. Had the flop, nice crisp crust on the back. Not alot of grease that was awesome. Sauce is top shelf.

Great crust, solid sauce but cheese is only okay. Overall great pizza

Little floppy, some crisp. Overall really tasty

Patsy gives John’s a run for its money for king of NY with this beauty. Once I got rid of the excessive basil leaves it was time to get to business. You gotta eat these slices quick as soon as they come out before they get cold. Sauce and cheese were top notch and the crust was crunchy and just burnt to a crisp and on point. Slices are two bites and your done, so you can easily devour the pie yourself. Top 5 in my book so Enjoy!!

The flavor of the sauce, spice, pepperoni and crust are fantastic. The crust was doughier on one side and perfect on the other. Besides that great pizza