15,566 views•80 likes
Order now on Slice
Order Patsy's Pizzeria
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
jessica.fannin6/17/22, 9:46 p.m.
It was good but boring I wish we had gotten the red pizza with only cheese. Crust is good but this “white pizza “ is like good bread with some ricotta smeared on it. Don’t try and jazz it up with pepper flakes because they’re not going to refill your water or anything even if there are only two other tables in there.
catherinev203.3056/11/22, 6:26 p.m.
This place scores higher than Pepe’s New Haven from the Prez and this was a disappointment. It’s good but not a NEW HAVEN pizza!
filipinokid045/31/22, 5:00 p.m.
Slowly but surely I’m getting a feel for El Prez’s liking for pizza. Though he scored a 8.6, this was another solid NY pizza spot and I feel confident to give it a 7.8.
pmw4/21/22, 1:03 a.m.
Sorry for lack of photo. This is a great pizza. Ages well too. Pepperoni is great on this. Adds some grease high quality pepperoni too. I have that around 8.9 maybe higher. Nice sweet sauce. Flavor packing. Cheese is better than most “fancy style” brick oven pies with an oily type crust that has perfect amount of thin and crust.
matthew.kelly34/8/22, 6:22 a.m.
Could care less if it’s not the original location… 🔥🔥🔥, everything on point sauce cheese and the perfect crust despite being delivered… can only imagine it’s better in person
garo2/7/22, 8:22 a.m.
Very flavorful red sauce and cheese. Crust was a bit flavorless is the only knock on it . Good pie
andrew.smith582/7/22, 12:51 a.m.
Looked great—always does. But ordered for takeout (3rd time) and it is always a slight disappointment. Not bad at all, just average—average toppings, average crust, average. And for a one-topping “large” pizza (it’s not large at all, it’s, well, average!) that’s over $30, you expect a bit more. Patsys in Whitestone (same franchise) is superlative. Every pie there is a 9.2-9.4. But this could be from almost any pizzeria in Murray Hill/Turtle Bay.
costlycost2/6/22, 3:27 a.m.
Incredible flavor to the sauce. I might go ahead and say the best pizza sauce I’ve ever had on a pie. Cheese was great, dough and crust could have used a little more flavor (maybe more salt?). Had the dough had more flavor you could be looking at the 9’s. Some NY flop. Old guy in there was buying us free pies because we liked it so much. 8.3, a monster score, that’s a review
robfromboston12/22/21, 9:06 p.m.
Great pizza. Perfect sauce with a little sweetness. Great crisp. Amazing crust.