Paulie Gee's Slice Shop

Tl;dr I get it’s the only slice shop in a 2 mile radius, but do not wait in the sheeple’s line. This very close to theme park pizza. Incredibly cheese heavy. But the cheese lacks impact. It’s quite bland and chewy, very chewy. The sauce can’t really find its way through. Zero flop though, oil is a bit much but passable. The stand out here is the crust. Surprisingly light and refined flavor. I’d honestly eat the crust as bread sticks and leave the rest. Their sit down brick oven pie restaurant a couple blocks away is far better though — an entirely different pizza

Did not live up to the hype. Too much flop, too much cheese which I didn’t even know was possible. Heavy slice not my style

Scores seem accurate. It’s a decent slice but doesn’t sound out very much and definitely not 8 worthy. Just a classic 7 worthy cheese slice

Excellent slice. Tomatoes are clean and fresh. Crispy AF. Grandma slice is even better!

Came here on the rebound of the famous Angelo's, which was nearby, but had at least a 1 hour wait, so I didn't do it. 1. Good staff, very accommodating. 2. The place looks a bit dated with the old fashion wood paneling around the place. 3. Pizza was very good. The cheese was on the creamy textured side. Not traditional, but very enjoyable. 4. I would come back here if need be and have lunch, and even maybe get a drink at their bar one day some time in the future!

Overall very good quality, including charred undercarriage and crisp; would rate the cheese 7.8 (perhaps the highest quality sub-8 in NYC), as it lacks some punch, and 8.2 for the Hellboy (great hot honey).

Freddie Prince review

Horrific service. Pizza sat forever before I asked staff if it was mine. No structure.

Grandma slice. Nice flop but thin for a grandma slice. A little too much oregano

Just the Facts: Whether you’re at MSG for a sports game, or to see a great concert, make sure to get this slice on your journey.

Mary Anne spoke with me for a few asking how I was doing and what I had planned for the day, she was very pleasant and I look forward to going back

Sexy ass slice uh pizza. Curvy as hell and she bites back

Meh - the triangle and grandma were fine, but nothing to write home about. Not much sauce and a little light on the dough. The thicc one had sesame seeds on the bottom, which I’m now learning I really don’t enjoy. Paulie’s got a lot to learn.

Lil more flavor in the dough then typical NY slice but nothing worth the hype

PHILADELPHIA LOCATION. Good pizza, too thin and spread out. Excessive flop, needed more sauce. Not a bad pizza - tastes like NY/NJ slice. Good sauce, not that Philly sweet sauce bullshit. Would have again maybe.

Stock photo. Went to paulie gees in MSG. Pretty good slice for nyc. Massive portion. Basically 2 slices together. Unreal pizza for a stadium

Freddie Prinze. Legit!

Sesame seeds on the square got this place in the 7s… otherwise, not great… I’ll take upstate slices over this anytime