Pauly's Pizza Joint

Half Mikey Show / half Christmas Pie ordered extra crispy. Solid pie!!

ZERO flop! Thicker than typical NY style, but that doesn't take away from the crisp or flavor. Super tasty, with quite a bit of oregano/seasoning. Sauce has a great tang! Very little grease for a pep pie! One of the best spots I've found in SD, and easily the best one on the north side of town.

Thin, light, good sauce. A little pricey

Really, really solid “in the 7s” pizza nestled in a strip mall in Miramar. Definitely a Mom and Pop shop with a super friendly staff and owner. While I wouldn’t make a special drive to come get this pizza from a couple hours away, if I lived in Miramar this would be the only pizza I ate. Cheese was as solid as it can get on a NY slice, and dough is on par with an above average pizza shop. Could definitely be crispier, as there was a significant amount of flop and the bottom lacked the char that gives a slice that important tangy-ness. It’s also hard to say if the sauce is made with fresh tomatoes or not, but I suspect not. I would be happy to know that I’m wrong though! All in all a good slice that needs some polishing to be fantastic and a San Diego staple. If you’re passing through, grab a slice, but don’t come from far away to get it.

I liked the flavor, but the pizza had a lot of flop. I wished they had cooked it just a little bit longer.

Tough to beat 2 slices and a drink for $7.56 but you can absolutely find more taste elsewhere. Good crust but leaves much to be desired.

Great slice, solid cheese/sauce ratio and decent crisp on the crust. Not quite in the 8's, I wouldn't drive the 15 minutes just to get this pizza on a regular basis. If I lived a little closer, I'd eat it every day.

Great slice of pie

Right up there with Bronx and Luigi.