Perillo's Pizzeria

My lady and I ordered slices. We loved them! The crust for me was the champion of the pie and the sauce won my girl over. The staff were so sweet and the old building was bursting with character. We will absolutely be back!

Whoa!! Drove out here for an 8.2 and that was rough. So much grease. So floppy. Wonder if the cheese was real. Super sweet staff. Just stick with the garlic knots and canned cheese sauce. Btw. Cash only. Such high hopes. Ouchie.

Drove 40 minutes to try this pizza. Ended up ordering half cheese and pep and one with eggplant, basil, and ricotta. Both were very good and huge - fresh dough, quality ingredients, nice crust. Busy place for good reason - The staff there were also very friendly. I would make the drive again.

Decided to try a pizza place a little off the beaten path off of I-74. Always love places like this. I liked the New York style. Crust and cheese were excellent. Sauce was ok and a little greasy. I gave it a 7.75. Jer gave it a 7.8.

This is a great traditional pizza joint, family owned and just outstanding pizza all around.

Best Pizza I’ve had in Indiana. The cost is also the best you will find around.

Delicious. Melts in your mouth with just the right crisp.

Okay Frankie, we are in North Salem in the middle of nowhere. Perillos... cash only establishment with a biker gang out front... In the middle of nowhere. This is where you come in Indiana to get whacked. Ridiculous mega flop. Should've gone with the traditional cheese because the middle is a bit of a mess. Probably could've left it in the oven for a few more minutes. But the flavor is fantastic. Really saves it. Perfect football pizza. This is one of these pizzas that is a 7.1 but will probably be a 7.6 if I had it for breakfast tomorrow.

We got the authentic Sicilian pie snd it was AMAZING. Perfect crust that was both firm and crisp yet light snd fluffy at the same time. A perfectly sweetened (not sugary!) sauce and some of the best mozzarella cheese I’ve had in YEARS!

It would be hard to find a better pizza in Indiana. Great sauce, great cheese, and great sauce!

Crazy good pizza. Everything about it is solid but the crust really stole the show: supported everything really well and had a nice crunch and chew. Perillo’s tops every place I’ve tried around Indy. It’s also cash only.

Best pizza I have had in state so far! These guys must not be from around here. Killer sauce, minimal flop. Can get a little greasy, and the crust could be a little thinner, but who am I to say anything but great things about Perillo’s!

Good pizza really liked the crust. There other dishes looked really good as well

A little greasy due to pepperoni. Plain pie better. About 15%-25% flop. One of the closest to NY/NJ style thin crust you can get in Central IN.