Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's Pizzeria

collab with @makelovetopizza69. dave nailed this review. similar pie to federici’s, but this is lighter. great crunch. my only critique is with the cheese. not too much flavor there. overall a solid bar pie. worth the travel from Wall after the pitch and putt (i won)

Pres hit the nail on the head with this one. Def in the 8s but no higher Ft. pizzaconnoisseur6969

Thin cheesy bar pie. Edible enough to win the whole pie challenge with ease! Great bar area too highly recommend it

Pretty good bar pie. Like the vibe of the place as well.

Thin and crispy!

Great bar pie. Thin & airy.

Super thin. Very good maybe ask for it a little more well done but all around a good pie.

Got the shirt!!

Classic, very good bar pie. Gotta love it. One of my personal favorites but I love thin crust so I’m biased. Worth the trip for sure. Eat a 22 inch pizza get a shirt

Fantastic thin crispy no flop

Great bar pie

Solid bar pie. Cheese is super tasty but not enough sauce for me personally. Crust is light & crispy so pretty solid too, you wont be disappointed here

Love pete an Elda’s best pizza on the shore

Good pie and great environment eating at the restaurant

Been going there for 30 years. Always order out in the summer. Unique crust, really nothing like it.

Super thin crust, you can eat so much.

Good bar pizza. Thin, light, crispy. Wish there was more sauce because the sauce was lacking in volume as well as taste. Cheese was tasty. Crust was crispy but didnt have much a taste. Still one of the better bar pies I've had. Would definitely recommend stopping here if you like bar pie style.