15,678 views•2,054 likes
ryan.rutherford5/15/20, 3:33 a.m.
I know there’s a lot of people out there who think this is an 8+ pie; but I can barely justify going over 7 for this. I love bar pies and this is a rather unique one, but it’s not nearly as good as the hype surrounding it. I love that it’s super thin, very light, just like a bar pie should be...but this dough is on par with a matzah cracker. There’s a difference between crispy and crunchy. The cheese is similar to the kind you’d find on frozen pizza, but actually doesn’t taste terrible. The sauce is average at best and not much to go around since it’s such a thin pie. I got this pizza to go; maybe I’ll have to try eating it there once we can dine out again. If it tastes better on-site, I will re-score but for now this sits at a very generous and somewhat disappointing 7.1
jars54/27/20, 8:09 p.m.
Pizza was good. Similar to Federicis in Freehold, NJ. No flop. Not too greasy.
jonnycage4/3/20, 7:16 p.m.
It was a good tasting pizza just very thin, you could eat a whole pie and still be hungry.
kevin.price3/29/20, 9:16 p.m.
Very thin great tasting and dominated immediately. Sauce and cheese had Goff flavor crust maybe could’ve been a touch crispier but can’t complain. Worth the drive maybe shouldve ordered two.
hollamor3/19/20, 1:56 a.m.
Great bar pizza!!! Thin Crispy and just right. I get Xtra cheese all the time makes it so much better!
joe.dellamura3/3/20, 2:49 a.m.
Good sauce good cheese; crust is a great thickness (very thin) but too brittle. Breaks apart when you try and fold it. Could stand to take a lesson from New Haven
yayitsck3/1/20, 4:12 p.m.
Overrated. Too thin. Like eating pizza on a cracker or piece of matzoh.
simon.krugly2/28/20, 10:34 p.m.
The tase is very good. Very good and tangy sauce. Good ratio of cheese to sauce. Although I like thin pizza, this is almost too thin. It has major flop and had to be held up by 2 hands because of how flimsy it is. I would eat it again, but wouldn’t drive more than 40 minutes for it.
rafibombs7322/24/20, 11:03 p.m.
Did the challenge and won. The pizza however was not what I expected. I knew it was thin crust but it was to much like a cracker. I got half caramelized onions which was amazing but the plain was decent at best.
fredtesta2/23/20, 6:24 p.m.
Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's Pizzeria one bite everybody knows the rules great atmosphere good food and the pizza was very good had a regular pie with extra cheese a pie with half sausage and half onion all were equally as good wish the crust was a little more crispy
11 views•3 likes
mikeymike3d932/18/20, 5:38 p.m.
Redemption review. Did my very first one bite review at Pete & Elda’s. Definitely thin and cheesy. Could eat an entire pie
luke.miller2/16/20, 5:04 p.m.
Loved the thin crust, felt like I could eat a whole pie and still want more. Great pizza.
michellev2/15/20, 10:41 p.m.
Excellent thin crust, passed the flop test, not too greasy, sauce and cheese were good. 8.6 !
jimrr32/14/20, 2:48 a.m.
Fantastic thin crust bar pizza. Crispy crust, flavor full sauce and nice cheese. **Little bonus, eat an XXL pizza and get a free T-shirt
crustdevil2/9/20, 2:26 p.m.
Cracker thin crust but didn’t have a lot of flavor to it. It was good overall.