Pizza Shuttle

I really liked this slice. Very bready, but good. I just finished a cheese slice (not pictured), which was delicious. Very light on sauce, so if you're a saucy gal this might not be the slice for you. However, the crust is very buttery and delicious. The mac and cheese one (pictured) tastes JUST like you're eating homemade mac and cheese...but with your hands. Overall...it's good!

I got a couple slices from Pizza Shuttle in Milwaukee. They were $5 a piece, which is reasonable for the size. The dough is very thick, to the point it negatively hinders the score. However, the cheese and toppings are solid, and the sauce compliments it. I give it a 6.7 considering you can get a quick slice here, and not break the bank, although it is nothing extraordinary.

Its drunk pizza, football pizza, college football, etc. If you get a slice right when it come.out of the oven tho, you wont be let down.

Pizza shuttle?! More like breadstick shuttle. Only thing worth getting here is a pack of smokes and a sixer of sticks.

Got the thin crust. No crisp but flavor is decent. Some bonus points for being open late and cheap delivery

Amazing and cheap I love it

I was hammered and the hotel said this was the only late night pizza they’d recommend. It wasn’t terrible but you have to set expectations after midnight. The thin crust was nice and greasy. Good enough toppings though the sausage would not stay on the slice. Kept falling off. I folded them NY style and dunked them into the dipping sauces which helped. Overall, it’ll hit the spot if you need it, but I’m sure their are better places during normal hours.

Milwaukee style thin crust - Hawaiian (wife was with me, I know). Overall - pizza was okay, presentation was horrible (see picture) half the pizza was slid over to one corner and sloppy, toppings tasted good, little sweet sauce almost no tang. The fact that this place is open late helps, because this pizza felt like it’s tailored for a 1am post bar crowd. The crust was EXTREMELY floppy, almost liquid. There was a lot of topping to crust ratio, which didn’t help. Again, post bar pizza, this would be amazing and definitely worth the order. BONUS REVIEW: Buffalo wings - 9.3 Honestly some of the best, meatiest, great sauced wings I’ve had in a long time. I would go there again for wings. Come here for late night pizza or wings, that’s a review.

It’ll do if you need food in your stomach but it’s gross

Really greasy. Little flop. Lots of peperonis. Good sauce but could use a tad bit more

The Chicago style is great (7.6), but hand tossed is very bland. Not impressed at all. Crust and cheese lack flavor; sauce is very light.

Good thick and flavorful pizza and at a reasonable price!

Solid Pizza. Good sauce

Buffalo chicken Mac... much better than their normal slices. Very good buffalo slice.

Good cheese, good sauce, barely any though

This is for you Max

Way too doughy but a solid, late night, bar close pizza.

Not bad something I could make in my oven

Massive thick slices...heavy Milwaukee flop...sauxe and crust were the best part

Open till 4am, toppings were delicious but crust on the “Chicago style” pizza wasn’t so Chicago style; it lacked flavor and was way tooooo doughy. But for a place that’s open till 4am, I guess you can’t expect anything over a 5-6 point average.