Pizza Time

I have been going to pizza time at least twice a year from Orlando for about 10 years and I only get the Sicilian I would put this Sicilian up against most this review is of the Sicilian. Quick note, the photos are not mine however they are of pizza to by far the best Sicilian pizza I've had in Central Florida.

Big slices. Good grandma pizza!

Good but very expensive. $ 9.75 per slice

While it’s good, it’s definitely not the second best in the country. Crust and cheese could have been cooked more, definitely some flop, and whatever seasoning they use is a little strong. Has that familiar New York flavor so it’s still an easy win for me. Would I come back to St. Augustine for this pizza? No. Would I come back for this pizza if I was in St. Augustine? Yes.

No complaints here. Saying it’s voted “2nd best pizza” is a bit of a long stretch but a solid slice nevertheless. Dough is good, sauce was good, cheese was good. There’s definitely better, but a solid slice that tasted good…like how pizza should taste.

Burrata Italian pizza. One of the best in the country

Great Spot. Food is good. Wanted to like it more. Crust was good. Sauce was delicious. Cheese blend was not my favorite. A bit too much. Wisconsin brick mushiness. The pepperoni would’ve been better on a charcuterie board than a pie. Definitely get the sangria special 2 for 1. Don’t let them fool you, they pack a punch. I would go back to try a different style or menu item.

Woh. So so good.

Good pizza. The experience not so much

It’s pizza, wouldn’t go crazy if you haven’t had it. Long line, the shoppers love a quick slice. Eh won’t be back in.

Really good slice. Loved it

Grandma slice was pretty good, little thick for my liking. Regular slice was just okay…. Didn’t wow me. Sauce was a little bland to me.

The grandma slice was for sure the best of the three I tried.

Good crunch,no sweetness to sauce, great cheese, burned the shit out of my mouth by was worth it.

Pretty good - might be better during the day- everything was reheated

Cheese was good, Grandma slice was ELITE. Asked for it well done to get a little extra crisp. Grandma slice was thick, but light, crispy, but fluffy. Awesome.

Got the burrata and the grandma. Good sauce and nice crunch. Not close to being the 2nd best pizza in America as trip advisor claims. It wouldn’t crack the top 20 in NYC alone but very good for Florida pizza. Worth a stop

Proportions way off, value for dollar not there.

Hands down the best white pizza you can find anywhere. Dom the owner makes authentic NY-style pizza. It is worth standing in line for!