Portland Pie Company

Can’t make a pie to save their life the last year or so. Asked for well done, sent the first one back as the bottom was still mostly raw dough. The second was mostly burnt on top with the undercarriage pictured. Very sad

No bragging rights at this place! Sauce was missing flavor, thin crust was soft and slightly undercooked but the cheese and pep saved this from a lower score!

Total generous score. Ordered just a small cheese, and I couldn't upload the photo I took. Total soggy flop. Zero cheese on the center of the pie. This place does have a great atmosphere. However, the pizza is totally lacking. I have friends I meet here because they love the place. But they never order pizza.

So many good pizza choices, this is the potato pizza. Taste just like a potato skin app

Marginal at best ...crust soggy.. go some where elese

🚮🚮🚮 if you want to spend 20$ for something my dog wouldn’t eat this is your place!

Awesome pizza with great flavor!

If you are from rural Maine, this pizza is in the 8s, but from other parts of this country, it’s too doughy and might be a 6. Flavor profile is pretty good.

This pizza is terrible. I have no idea why it has such a high score.

I was expecting a lot more from these guys. I was very disappointed

Decent pizza, different style sauce and cheese were good. Crust wasn’t great. Ton of flop. That’s a review.

Could be amazing. Needs to be tightened up a little bit. A little less grease, a little less flop and a little more crisp would put this easily into the 8s. Sauce was delicious. Pizza just kind of fell apart and lots of flop for me. High hopes if they take some steps to improve.

Excellent dough cooked very well a strong 8.9

Small slices, not a lot of sauce, chewy dough

Pretty Basic, not much makes it unique, not enough sauce, crust not very crispy, average slice overall

We’re new to Maine and hailing from a hot bed of some of the BEST pizza in the country, New Haven, CT, this pizza snob has some very high standards. I’m partial to the classic Margarita pie so I searched for one in the greater Portland area and every place claimed ignorance(first 8 tries!)except this wonderful place! Very accommodating with lots of choices: crust types, flavors and thicknesses and lots of toppings. I went with the Margarita, thin crust garlic crust with caramelized onions and peppers and it was superb! Lots of great beer selections, extremely friendly staff and great atmosphere. The beet salad that accompanied it was awesome as well. I’ll be back with the whole clan!