Post Alley Pizza

Good cheese and marinara flavor. Little flop. Could use more crunch. Kid = 6.9, dad = 6.5, dog = 9.9.

Overhyped in tourism area. Very good pizza for work lunch though.

One slice of cheese only and one pepperoni. Both had crisp, thin crusts, virtually no flop and generally decent. Light on sauce, light on toppings, and lacking flavor or seasoning.

Great slice, I’m not sure what the negative reviews are from. I am not rating on service although there was nothing wrong with it the pizza is good. Great char underneath and great crisp.

Great crust!

This pizza blew me away. Went in to get out of the rain on a Monday afternoon and was not expecting to have the best slice of pizza ive ever had. The slice has no flop, impossibly thin but firm undercarriage and excellent crisp. Perfect amount of cheese and pepperoni coverage. So many pizza places undercook their pizza but this place wasn't afraid to properly cook their pizza. If I ever get back to Seattle this will be a must eat again.

I was very eager to try this place. The pizza was huge, tasty but greasy. I would give it another try but only cheese.

I initially gave them a decent score however, the staff is very rude to the point of turning their backs to customers just for asking a question….. and they seem to cook their pizza the day before and then heat it back up upon ordering! I generally get there when they open and they have to reheat my order???? Very odd but won’t be back again

Good pie, sauce and cheese. Decent flop.

You can get a piping hot NY slice here in Seattle! The pepperoni slice wasn’t greasy and had a great undercarriage. There also was a phenomenal sauce to cheese ratio. Bonus: they serve Mexican Cokes here. 8.2/10. That is all.

Solid slices in Seattle

Slices are unreal, haven’t tried the whole pies. Super light, airy dough, phenomenal undercarriage, not too much shit on top. The elite Seattle slice shop

First time here and I was pleasantly surprised by this spot! The flavorful sauce and salty pepperoni were a harmonious duo. The other toppings were a bonus! Just a pepperoni or cheese slice would be just as delicious without the extras. Definitely coming back here again!

Big fan of the simplicity to amazing taste ratio

Basic as it gets. Not a ton of sauce. Nice crisp. Your average pizza

Great undercarriage. Hold it by the crust and it stands taught. The cheese is a solid New York slice, minor complexity with the cheese, but not enough to give it the 8. The daily slice (pepperoni, mushroom, and peppers) was excellent. They took the care to have their own red pepper flake blend and use a good parm which you should use to decorate the pizzas with. Solid slices. Good prices. Better than Roccos

D enough.